?
Alfred Schütz's Sociology as a Naive Science
Basic Research Programme
,
2015.
No. WP BRP 93/HUM/2015.
Yudin G.
Alfred Schütz has paid considerable attention to the position of scientist in the world and particularly to that of social scientist. His analyses make extensive use of phenomenological concepts and contain detailed descriptions of scientific cognitive style in its relation to the everyday life. However, Schütz is surprisingly silent on the motives that could justify quitting the ordinary 'world of working' and entering the scientific attitude. This paper discusses whether the Schütz normative justification for science can be deduced from Husserl's philosophy of science. It is argued that despite the fact that Schütz was in fact considerably influenced by Husserl's system of science suggested in 'Ideas II', the two thinkers diverge radically on the cultural mission and methodology of science. While Husserl advocates the critical method of reduction as the sole way to pursue genuine science, Schütz in fact explores the possibility of building a 'naive science'. He accepts relying on ordinary knowledge in social science and ends up by rejecting the methodology of reduction in general. Schütz's opposition to the idea of science contained in Husserl's phenomenology, together with his neglect of normative grounding of science, suggest that he considered the value of science as laying beyond rational philosophical justification
Yudin G., Human Studies 2016 Vol. 39 No. 4 P. 547-568
Alfred Schütz is often credited with providing sociology with a firm ground derived from phenomenology of science and justifying it as a science operating within natural attitude. Although his project of social science draws extensively on Edmund Husserl’s theory of attitudes, it would be incorrect to assume that Schütz shares with the founder of phenomenology ...
Added: June 4, 2016
Yudin G., Логос 2016 Т. 26 № 1 С. 108-114
Элементы критики Гуссерля» — текст, который содержит в себе загадку. В последние годы жизни Гуссерль настойчиво подчеркивал, что именно Финк лучше всех понимает его мысль, и фактически сделал Финка своим соавтором. «Шестая картезианская медитация», результат совместной работы Гуссерля и Финка, тесно переплетается с текстами поздних рукописей Гуссерля, которые лишь в последнее время становятся доступны широкому ...
Added: May 27, 2016
Nikitina E. B., Социосфера 2013 № 2 С. 74-76
The aim of the following article is to examine the reasons why negative experience tends to be more deeply ingrained in human memory than positive one. The article, written in the form of a cross-disciplinary study incorporating elements of psychology and social science, is the author‘s attempt to arrive at a convincing conclusion relying on ...
Added: November 5, 2013
Yampolskaya A., Логос 2016 Т. 26 № 1 С. 74-78
Статья посвящена научным и личным взаимоотношениям между Гуссерлем и Финком, а также влиянию Финка на французскую феноменологию. В работе проблематизируется понятие "верного ученика" внутри феноменологической традиции: означает ли "верность" отсутствие критики по отношению к трудам основоположника, или, напротив, такую критику до определенной степени предполагает? А если да, то до какой именно степени? ...
Added: June 22, 2016
Shkundin M. Z., Безопасность Евразии 2009 № 3 С. 463-464
Рецензия на книгу Кортунова С.В. Национальная и международная безопасность. Концептуальные основы. Издательский дом ГУ-ВШЭ. Москва: 2007. Рецензируемая работа посвящена одной из базовых проблем отечественного обществоведения
безопасности в самом широком смысле этого слова, как национальной, так и международной. С первых же страниц исследования автор последовательно придерживается деятельностного подхода к анализу прошлого, настоящего и будущего, противопоставляя его общепринятому ...
Added: February 24, 2013
Drozdova D., Гуманитарные исследования в Восточной Сибири и на Дальнем Востоке 2018 Т. 46 № 4 С. 100-106
This paper presents the findings of a research conducted in Russian and French archives which sheds new light on early life and intellectual biography of a famous philosopher and historian of science Alexandre Koyré (1892-1964). During the investigation some important details of his revolutionary activity in Russian Empire were discovered. A special attention is paid ...
Added: January 10, 2019
Laurukhin A., Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология 2014 № 4 (28) С. 318-329
The article examines Husserl project of the renovation of European cultural mankind in context of the genesis of Husserl’s practical philosophy, existential motivations for the emergence of the idea of renovation (Erneuerung) and in perspective of its adaptations to the contemporary. The key point of the article – Husserl’s thesis about internationalization through the phenomenological ...
Added: November 11, 2014
Chernavin G., Annales de Phénoménologie 2016 No. 15 P. 55-63
The article provides the analysis of the motive of the profound incomprehensibility of the doxa, solidified in the form of the obvious, by Edmund Husserl and Eugen Fink. The discussion with the philsophy of Martin Heidegger is also provided. The article compares the phenomenological method with the technique of "Er-staunen" (estrangement). The general overview of ...
Added: October 1, 2015
Bankovskaya S., Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Социология 2020 Т. 20 № 2 С. 212-225
Abstract. The author considers the construction of the ‘temporal sociologism’ by A. Schütz from the ‘general thesis of the alter ego’ to the Stranger and the Homecomer. The background and starting point of this construction is Schütz’s criticism of the Husserlian egological approach to the basic category of the Other and the radicalization of phenomenological ...
Added: November 2, 2020
Chernavin G., Annales de Phénoménologie 2018 No. 17 P. 117-145
The article discusses the mode of existence of the world as described in Husserl's philosophy. The central concept is that of the "relative apodicticity". The world-existence is related ton the continous concordance of the experience. The interpretation is based on the partially unpublished manuscript Husserl's - B I 13. ...
Added: October 31, 2018
Korbut A., Социология власти 2014 № 1 С. 10-30
The article deals with the problem of habits and the possibilities of their phenomenological description. It is shown that the problem of habits is the key to phenomenology and sociology as a sciences of taken for granted, everyday world. The need to turn to phenomenological understanding of habit is determined by the fact that this ...
Added: May 22, 2014
Sepp H. R., Chernavin G., Lo K. et al., Nordhausen : Verlag Traugott Bautz GmbH, 2018
The collective monogrtaph "Phänomenologie und Buddhismus" brings together research articles from philosophers as well as from specialists in oriental studies. In the center of attention stays the intersection between the phenomenological philosophical discourse and the (mostly far-eastern) buddhist tradition. ...
Added: April 14, 2018
Yampolskaya A., Вопросы философии 2012 № 9 С. 157-166
Phenomenological reduction assures the scientific standing of the phenomenological investigations. But it is also an existential situation, where philosophizing subject finds out that he is put into question. The splitting of the I generates not only “original phenomenon of the world” as well as transcendental subjectivity that constitutes it; it is also a recursive act ...
Added: January 25, 2014
Chernavin G., Yampolskaya A., Continental Philosophy Review 2019 Vol. 52 No. 1 P. 91-113
We investigate the parallelism between aesthetic experience and the practice of phenomenology using Viktor Shklovsky's theory of 'estrangement' (ostranenie). In his letter to Hugo von Hofmannsthal, Husserl claims that aesthetic and phenomenological experiences are similar; in the perception of a work of art we change our attitude in order to concentrate on how the things ...
Added: October 19, 2017
Финк О., Логос 2016 Т. 26 № 110 С. 47-60
In his work "Critiquing Husserl: Elements", Eugen Fink reviews the main hurdles encountered by phenomenological research in philosophy. Among these hurdles he lists the interweaving between moments of description, analysis and speculation; the outer-philosophical presuppositions conficting with the claim of presuppositionlessness; the non-thought relation to the philosophical tradition; contradictions between the philosophical project and the ...
Added: October 15, 2016
Chernavin G., Annales de Phénoménologie 2015 No. 14 P. 97-120
The article discusses the flexible or mouveable architectonics of phenomenological philosophy. The special attention is given to the problems of "Sinnbildung" and "Urstiftung". The phenomenology is considered to be not a philosophical system, but an open research project. ...
Added: April 8, 2015
Chernavin G., Вестник Русской христианской гуманитарной академии 2020 Т. 21 № 1 С. 73-82
В работах Я. С. Друскина проводится то, что сам автор называет «радикальной феноменологической редукцией» к «внутреннему молчанию», которая, по его утверждению, позволяет агенту такой радикальной редукции «быть ничем». При этом Я. C. Друскин делает важную оговорку: его интересует «феноменологическая редукция, если она действительно есть…», т. е. ее существование не гарантировано. Такая оговорка придает «радикальной феноменологической ...
Added: March 17, 2021
Chernavin G., Russian Studies in Philosophy 2016 Vol. 54 No. 1 P. 48-61
The article analyzes some key motives of both classical German phenomenology (focusing on Edmund Husserl) and contemporary French phenomenology (focusing on Marc Richir). The theme of sense-formation, a recurring thread throughout Husserl's entire body of work, serves as a discussion starting point.
A special emphasis is put on one of Husserl's posthumously published texts from 1933, ...
Added: September 20, 2016
Смит Ф., Социологическое обозрение 2008 Т. 7 № 2 С. 3-23
Philip Smith is one of the main followers of the strong program in cultural sociology. Along with Jeffrey C. Alexander, he is a co-author of a number of works which are constitutive for the tradition itself. Several of those are the strong program in cultural sociology manifesto; some texts which affirm late-Durkheimian program to be ...
Added: September 24, 2012
Nikitina E. B., Сборники конференций НИЦ Социосфера 2011 № 42 С. 72-84
The article "Russian Intelligentsia as a Historical and Social Phenomenon" is dedicated to the problems of the disappearance of the so called "intelligentsia" in the post-soviet society and the need to recreate it under new living and cultural conditions. The main purpose of the article is to make a careful and thorough analysis of the ...
Added: November 15, 2012
Н. Новгород : Нижегородский филиал НИУ ВШЭ, 2010
В сборнике представлены научные статьи, подготовленные по материалам научно-исследовательских работ студентов Нижегородского филиала Государственного университета – Высшей школы экономики, участвующих в 2009/2010 учебном году в конкурсах НФ ГУ-ВШЭ на лучшую научно-исследовательскую работу.
Результаты выполненных работ были заслушаны 20 апреля 2010 г. на VIII научно-практической конференции студентов и преподавателей НФ ГУ-ВШЭ «Современные проблемы в области экономики, менеджмента, ...
Added: June 30, 2012
Cagnin C., Havas A., Saritas O., Technological Forecasting and Social Change 2013 Vol. 80 No. 3 P. 379-385
This paper reflects on the potential of future-oriented analysis (FTA) to address major change and to support decision-makers and other stakeholders in anticipating and dealing with transformations. It does so by critically reflecting on the selected papers for this special issue as well as on the discussions that took place at the fourth Seville International ...
Added: February 7, 2013
Bek M. A., Bek N. N., Sheresheva M. Y. et al., Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing 2013 Vol. 28 No. 3 P. 240-259
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to develop and test models explaining the unsatisfactory innovation activity of Russian firms and the main obstacles to innovation cluster development. Design/methodology/approach: Based on statistical analysis and the results of a pilot survey of 192 local businessmen, followed by imitation modeling analysis, the study tests hypotheses regarding the ...
Added: March 29, 2013
Zaborovskaya A., Kryshtanovsky A., Titova N. L. et al., М. : Издательский дом ГУ-ВШЭ, 2002
В книге рассматриваются организационно-финансовые схемы адаптации вуза в условиях кризиса бюджетного финансирования, которые были разработаны в Центре образовательной политики ГУ-ВШЭ при поддержке НФПК.
Книга рассчитана на специалистов в области экономики и управления высшего профессионального образования, а также может быть использована для подготовки специалистов сферы образования. ...
Added: February 10, 2012