Bad management, skimping, or both? The relationship between cost efficiency and loan quality in Russian banks

Mikhail E. Mamonov

Working paper

Bad management, skimping, or both? The relationship between cost efficiency and loan quality in Russian banks

Financial Economics. FE. Высшая школа экономики, 2013. No. 19.

Mikhail E. Mamonov.

This paper investigates the relationship between operating cost efficiency and the loan quality of Russian banks. It tries to answer the question whether it is always beneficial for banks to be highly cost efficient (the “bad management” hypothesis) or whether this higher cost efficiency could mean inadequate spending on borrower screening, which could subject banks to higher credit risk exposures in the future (the “skimping” hypothesis)? Our main result implies that, while the “bad management” hypothesis holds on average for the banking sector as a whole, the “skimping” hypothesis could be the case for those Russian banks that are not just highly cost efficient, as predicted by Berger and DeYoung (1997) for US banks, but that at the same time pursue aggressive strategies in the market for loans to households and non-financial firms, especially during the pre-crisis periods when banks are too optimistic to pay increased attention to the quality of borrowers in order to extract higher profits in the short run. Interestingly, we show that the “skimping” strategy is not the case for those Russian banks that demonstrate a lower equity-to-assets ratio and that are highly cost efficient at the same time because, as we believe, higher financial leverage forces these banks to filter out low quality borrowers to be able to repay borrowed funds. From perspective of regulatory policy, these conclusions provide clear arguments in favor of differential prudential regulation in Russia, which could, if being implemented, positively affect the loan quality of both banks that are skimpers (through restricting loans growth by higher capital adequacy requirements and/or increased payments to the Russian Deposit Insurance Agency) and banks that are not (through eliminating incentives to grow too fast), thus improving the stability of the banking sector as a whole.

Research target: Economics and Management (including Public Administration)

Priority areas: economics

Language: English

Full text (PDF, 537 Kb)

Text on another site

Keywords: Russian banks bad management skimping cost efficiency credit risk

Publication based on the results of: Research on Russian Economic Development focused on crucial sectors and spheres of Russian Economy. Outline of possible exit paths from prolonged economic crisis of Russian and world economies. Construction of medium- and long-term forecasts of social and economic development(2012)

Экономика и управление: проблемы и перспективы развития. Сборник научных статей по итогам международной научно-практической конференции г.Волгоград 15-16 ноября 2010 г.

Ч. 1. Волгоград: Волгоградское научное издательство, 2010.

Added: Jan 18, 2013

Экономическая активность населения России в 1990-е гг.

Гимпельсон В. Е. Проблемы рынка труда. WP3. Высшая школа экономики, 2002. № 01.

Added: Mar 26, 2013

Internal Ratings-based Approach и Creditrisk+: преимущества и недостатки методологий (концентрация портфелей российских банков и ошибка IRB Approach)

Разумовский П. А. Экономическая политика. 2010. № 4. С. 154-175.

Added: Oct 23, 2012

Stochastic approach to integrated modeling of credit and interest rate risk

Andreev N. A., Lapshin V. A. Информационные системы и математические методы в экономике (электронный научный журнал). 2012. No. 3. P. 56-61.

The paper presents a review of stochastic framework for term structure modeling and shows comparative advantages of commonly used techniques. The main application of the research is coherent modeling of credit and interest rate risk for Euro zone issuers.

Added: Jul 24, 2012

Обновляемый образовательный ресурс "Экономическая школа НИУ ВШЭ"

2012.

Added: Feb 22, 2013

Banking system stabilization and public sector expansion in Russia

Vernikov A. V. In bk.: Comparing Responses to Global Instability - 11-th Bi-Annual Conference of European Association for Comparative Economic Studies. Tartu: University of Tartu, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, 2010. P. 1-15.

Bank stabilization measures adopted by the Russian authorities since 2008 have benefited core state-owned financial institutions to a greater extent than other market participants. Public sector keeps swelling at the expense of domestic private sector. According to the author’s methodology, by January 2010 state-controlled banks possessed over 50 percent of all bank assets, thus putting Russia in the same league with China and India. Development banking and policy lending expand. A feature distinguishing Russia is gradual substitution of direct state control by indirect state ownership in the shape of corporate pyramids headed by state-owned enterprises and state-owned banks. We construct a dataset of bank-level statistical data for the period between 2001 and 2010 and find that quasi-private banks (indirectly state-owned banks) were the fastest growing subgroup. Nationalization and rehabilitation of failed banks was carried out by state-controlled banks and entities rather than by federal executive authorities directly. We suggest that the response of the Russian authorities to bank instability was consistent with long-term trends in the banking system evolution. Anti-crisis measures of 2008-9 re-aligned the sector with the traditional model of banking that rests upon dominant state-owned banks, directed lending, protectionism, administrative interference and elements of price controls. Increased government ownership of banks and control over lending activity are unlikely to be fully dismantled after the crisis is over. This scenario can nevertheless accommodate a tactical retreat of the state from non-core assets in the financial sector, leaving control over 3 largest institutions intact.

Added: Oct 2, 2012

Russian banking: A comeback of the state

Vernikov A. V. Economics Working Paper. UCL SSEES Centre for Comparative Economics, 2010. No. 104.

The purpose of this paper is to assess the size of public sector within the Russian banking industry. We identify and classify at least 78 state-influenced banks. We distinguish between banks that are majority-owned by federal executive authorities or Central Bank of Russia, by sub-federal (regional and municipal) authorities, by state-owned enterprises and banks, and by "state corporations". We estimate their combined market share to have reached 56% of total assets by July 1, 2009. Banks indirectly owned by public capital are the fastest-growing group. Concentration is increasing within the public sector of the industry, with the top five state-controlled banking groups in possession of over 49% of assets. We observe a crowding out and erosion of domestic private capital, whose market share is shrinking from year to year. Several of the largest state-owned banks now constitute a de facto intermediate tier at the core of the banking system. We argue that the direction of ownership change in Russian banking is different from that in CEE countries.

Added: Sep 3, 2012

Кредитный анализ в коммерческом банке

Хасянова С. Ю. М.: НИЦ Инфра-М, 2018.

In textbook the main issues connected with organization of credit analysis in a commercial bank were considered. The role of credit analysis in risk management system is shown. The methodology and specific methods for assessing the creditworthiness of borrowers used by banks are set out by complex approach. The textbook includes international recommendations for introduction of internal credit risk assessment systems in banks. With the aim at presenting the material examples from the practice of commercial banks, analytical tables, diagrams and figures were used.

Added: Feb 8, 2016

Влияние выбора целей и инструментов политики денежных властей на уязвимость экономик

Трунин П. В., Дробышевский С. М., Евдокимова Т. В. М.: Издательский дом «Дело» РАНХиГС, 2012.

Added: Mar 26, 2013

IPO of Russian Banks: the Crisis Effect on the Market Value of the Stocks

Balkovskaya D., Stulova N. International Journal of Business and Social Science. 2012. Vol. 3. No. 1. P. 59-65.

The process of the IPO of banks in Russia is its infancy but the rapid growth is forecasted. This context raises the issue of the factors determining the floated banks stock value. The results of the research on 2007-2009 Russian data showed that the bank stock price is dependent on the macroeconomic indicators (such as the oil prices and the Dow Jones index volatility) and the some banking system indicators(the interbank interest rate, the bank’s ROA, and ROE). However, the results adjusted to the global financial crisis effect proved to exclude the ROE factor and showed the dependence of the stocks prices of the floated banks from the historic trend of the American economy. The models developed are of the practical application and can be used by the institutional as well as the private investors.

Added: Sep 29, 2012

Russian banking: The state makes a comeback?

Vernikov A. V. BOFIT Discussion Papers. DP. Bank of Finland Institute for Economies in Transition, 2009. No. DP 24/2009.

The purpose of this paper is to carefully assess the size of public sector within the Russian banking industry. We identify and classify at least 78 state-influenced banks. For the state-owned banks, we distinguish between those that are majority-owned by federal executive authorities or Central Bank of Russia, by sub-federal (regional and municipal) authorities, by state-owned enterprises and banks, and by "state corporations". We estimate their combined market share to have reached 56% of total assets by July 1, 2009. Banks indirectly owned by public capital are the fastest-growing group. Concentration is increasing within the public sector of the industry, with the top five state-controlled banking groups in possession of over 49% of assets. We observe a crowding out and erosion of domestic private capital, whose market share is shrinking from year to year. Several of the largest state-owned banks now constitute a de facto intermediate tier at the core of the banking system. We argue that the direction of ownership change in Russian banking is different from that in CEE countries.

Added: Sep 3, 2012

Стресс-тестирование в системе раннего оповещения о финансовых кризисах: применение к анализу устойчивости российской банковской системы

Пестова А. А., Солнцев О. Г. В кн.: XIII Международная научная конференция по проблемам развития экономики и общества. В 4 кн. Кн. 2.. Кн. 2. М.: Издательский дом НИУ ВШЭ, 2012. С. 71-86.

Added: Mar 15, 2013

The input of informal capital into the entrepreneurial activity in the international context

Murzacheva E. I. In bk.: Theory of Entrepreneurship: new results and prospects (Research papers). M.: 2011. P. 103-135.

The paper considers the financial choice of entrepreneurs at their initial stage of development as a key criterion of a new firm potential riskiness. The main objective of the research is the methodology elaboration aimed at the numerical estimation of the role of informal financial resources involved in the small business creation. Two fundamental considerations have been tested. The former implies that informal investment is a substitution for unavailable formal sources, including venture capital (because of the lack of essential networks and connections with business associations). The latter performs the opposite concept of negative effects: economic reasoning discouragement and inefficient resources allocation. A special technique is introduced in order to measure the credit quality of early entrepreneurial activity and to estimate its contingency with the financial strategy. The methodology validation is realised under Global Entrepreneurship Monitor conceptual framework. The results are received for 42 countries in 2006-2007, depicting the influence of informal support on potential losses under the second consideration. As a result, informal investments are inefficient when the concentration of credit risk in the economy is rather high. Investorsђ expectations about the entrepreneurial growth of the firm are pessimistic, anticipated returns on investments are too low to be economically reasonable. The outcome leads to the irrecoverable losses, both financial (short-received profitability) and nonfinancial (decreased output, the lack of innovativeness, flexibility, and inventiveness).

Added: Sep 6, 2013

Институт минимальной заработной платы в странах ОЭСР

Вишневская Н. Т. Проблемы рынка труда. WP3. Высшая школа экономики, 2005. № 03.

The paper examines the institute of minimum wage in developed and transition economies and in a number of the developing countries. First of all the institutional mechanism of minimum wage fixing is considered. One of the sections explores the dynamics of absolute and relative levels of minimum wage. The special attention is paid to the impact of the institute of minimum wage on the labour market. The author considers the mechanism of transmission of the minimum wage increases on the employment and unemployment dynamics. The paper also contains the result of the empirical research. The experience of many countries witnesses that large increases in minimum wage levels lead to the stagnation of the employ-ment, especially of the disadvantaged groups. The negative effect is larger for the companies with higher share of labour costs and more active use of unqualified labour, that is small businesses and agricultural enterprises. One of the main conclusions is that the minimum wage is not an effective tool of the poverty reduction as the majority of the recipients live in households of average and upper average income.

Added: Oct 13, 2012

Direct and indirect state ownership on banks in Russia

Vernikov A. V. Munich Personal RePEc Archive. University Library of Munich, 2010. No. 21373.

This paper uses the banking industry case to show that the boundaries of public property in Russia are blurred. A messy state withdrawal in 1990s left publicly funded assets beyond direct reach of official state bodies. While we identify no less than 50 state-owned banks in a broad sense, the federal government and regional authorities directly control just 4 and 12 institutions, respectively. 31 banks are indirectly state-owned, and their combined share of state-owned banks’ total assets grew from 11% to over a quarter between 2001 and 2010. The state continues to bear financial responsibility for indirectly owned banks, while it does not benefit properly from their activity through dividends nor capitalization nor policy lending. Such banks tend to act as quasi private institutions with weak corporate governance. Influential insiders (top-managers, current and former civil servants) and cronies extract their rent from control over financial flows and occasional appropriation of parts of bank equity.

Added: Sep 3, 2012

Численность и состав российской бюрократии: между советской номенклатурой и госслужбой гражданского общества

Гимпельсон В. Е. Проблемы рынка труда. WP3. Высшая школа экономики, 2002. № 05.

Added: Mar 26, 2013

Государственная политика в области ограничения курения: какие меры наиболее эффективны

Засимова Л. С. Вопросы государственного и муниципального управления. 2010. № 4. С. 68-81.

Smoking is a problem, bringing signifi cant social and economic costs to Russiansociety. However, ratifi cation of the World health organization Framework conventionon tobacco control makes it possible to improve Russian legislation accordingto the international standards. So, I describe some measures that should be taken bythe Russian authorities in the nearest future, and I examine their effi ciency. By studyingthe international evidence I analyze the impact of the smoke-free areas, advertisementand sponsorship bans, tax increases, etc. on the prevalence of smoking, cigaretteconsumption and some other indicators. I also investigate the obstacles confrontingthe Russian authorities when they introduce new policy measures and the public attitudetowards these measures. I conclude that there is a number of easy-to-implementanti-smoking activities that need no fi nancial resources but only a political will.

Added: Oct 2, 2012

Макроэкономическое обоснование антикризисного управления организациями

Березовский Д. С. Вестник Московского государственного университета печати. 2011. № 2.

Added: Mar 3, 2014

Оценка эффективности деятельности компании на основе ее интеллектуального потенциала

Хинина Н. С. Казанская наука. 2010. № 4. С. 103-109.

One of the most important indicators of company's success is the increase of its value. The article investigates traditional methods of company's value assessment and the evidence that the application of these methods is incorrect in the new stage of economy. So it is necessary to create a new method of valuation based on the new main sources of company's success that is its intellectual capital.

Added: Nov 7, 2012

Правовые институты в России 2000-2007 годах: взгляд со стороны бизнеса

Яковлев А. А. Общественные науки и современность. 2008. № 4. С. 21-37.

Added: Sep 22, 2012

На океанских волнах. Россия в мировом кризисе

Уринсон Я. М. Вестник Европы. 2014. № 38-39.

Added: Feb 5, 2018

Применение различных вариантов правила передачи голосов

Карпов А. В., Вольский В. И. Полития: Анализ. Хроника. Прогноз. 2011. № 2. С. 162-174.

Added: Jun 24, 2011