What do the Marxist "Dialectics of Cognition" and Laratos's "Sophisticated Falsificationism" have in common?
Epistemology and Philosophy of Science. 2018. Vol. 55. No. 3. P. 35-40.
The article shows that Marxist dialectics and the social
philosophy of science, whose influence was obvious in Imre
Lakatos’s early philosophical experiments, underwent substantial
reinterpretation during the mature period of his creative
activity. Being implicit heuristic sources of his “sophisticated
falsificationism” or methodology of scientific research programs,
they take on a conceptual form in which they lose the “excess” of
authentic contents. Therefore, the philosophical views of “mature
Lakatos” may be called close to the Marxist philosophy of science
only with many important reservations and specifications.
Research target: Philosophy, Ethics, and Religious Studies
, В кн. : Имре Лакатос: Избранные произведения по философии и методологии науки. : Академический проект, 2008. С. 9-21.
Имре Лакатос (1922-1974), родился в Венгрии, диссертацию по философским вопросам математики готовил в Московском университете. За диссидентские взгляды в конце 40-х годов провел два года в тюрьме. После венгерских событий 1956 г. эмигрировал, работал в Лондонской школе экономики и политических наук, где стал наиболее ярким среди последователей Поппера. Лакатоса называли "рыцарем рациональности", поскольку он отстаивал ...
Added: April 24, 2013
, , Журнал Новой экономической ассоциации 2022 Т. 53 № 1 С. 181-200
This paper is devoted to clarification of Marx’s view of man in terms of his special humanism and materialism. The authors argue that Marx’s works contain normative elements and the basic value for him is free human self-realization. But this self-realization doesn’t serve as a mean for embodiment of certain human ideals; it is the ...
Added: September 21, 2021
, Studies in East European Thought 2022 Vol. 74 No. 3 P. 345-357
The paper investigates the dependence of Leo Tolstoy’s ethical, religious and political ideas on Benedict Spinoza’s philosophy. The Soviet philosopher Valentin Asmus offered a solution to this problem by attempting to emphasize rationalist elements in Tolstoy’s teachings while glossing over his religious inclinations. Asmus treated Tolstoy’s “life’s religion” as a peculiar form of humanist ethics, ...
Added: September 18, 2021
Изображение времени в научных диаграммах: решение Галилео Галилеем задачи о движении свободно падающего тела
, Праксема. Проблемы визуальной семиотики 2021 Т. 30 № 4 С. 58-80
The textbook narrative of the Scientific Revolution of the 17th century says that the early modern transformation of physics and mechanics was grounded in mathematization, that is, the application of mathematical principles and procedures to physical entities and events. However, such a transformation faces a major obstacle: compared to geometry, mechanics includes an additional dimension, ...
Added: November 6, 2021
, , Вопросы философии 2020 № 6 С. 5-10
Conversation of editor of the journal Voprosy Filosofii I.O. Shchedrina with Associate Member of the Russian Academy of Sciences, Professor, Head of the Department of History of World Philosophy (Faculty of Philosophy, Moscow State University), V.V. Vasilyev on the problems of modern philosophy, philosophy of consciousness, history of philosophy, philosophical journal. ...
Added: October 28, 2020
, , Вестник Санкт-Петербургского университета. Философия и конфликтология 2019 Т. 35 № 1 С. 83-91
The historization of the methodological consciousness of a scientist (both in the field of natural science and in the field of humanitarian research) is becoming the most important factor of concrete scientific work. At the same time, the scientist’s awareness of the historical dimension of cognition and, accordingly, the historization of methodological reflection contains the ...
Added: October 28, 2020
, Isis 2019 Vol. 110 No. 4 P. 1-4
Superstition is an awkward category for historians of science, and they do not typically use it. Scientists, on the contrary, frequently do, often in loose terms to describe those beliefs that conflict with or simply ignore what science has revealed about nature’s truths. Occasionally the term has been weaponized to decry claims of which they decidedly do not ...
Added: December 8, 2019
, Вопросы философии 2022 № 7 С. 66-74
The term “idea” was used in history of thought in three main meanings: Plato’s eidos; transcendental ides of pure reason in Kants first “Kritik”; and understanding of simple and complicated ideas in the Empiricism of Modernity. Each of these interpretations is in correlation with definite seeing of the University, as well as of the place ...
Added: August 31, 2022
, Вопросы философии 2019 № 7 С. 43-51
Max Weber’s lecture “Science as a vocation and a profession” sums up a hundred years history of the German “Humboldtian” university. From the reflections on the academic career in Germany of his time he passes to the feeling of “inner vocation” and to the science as Weltanschauung. As a sociologist of religion Weber retraces the ...
Added: July 25, 2019
, , et al., Systema: connecting matter, life, culture and technology 2013 Vol. 1 No. 3 P. 04-13
Cybernetics and Systems Research (CSR) were developed in the mid-twentieth century, offering the possibility of describing and comparing different phenomena using the same language. The concepts, which originated in CSR have spread to practically all disciplines, many now used within the scientific study of complex systems. CSR has the potential to contribute to the solution ...
Added: April 15, 2014
, Epistemology and Philosophy of Science 2018 Vol. 55 No. 2 P. 165-179
This paper analyses different retrospective links between the scientia generalis by Leibniz and the philosophical, rhetorical and encyclopaedic traditions of the Renaissance and Early Modern Europe, emphasising the influence of Aristotle’s’ “Metaphysics” on the genesis of the concept of universal science in 17th century philosophy. ...
Added: May 10, 2018
, Вопросы философии 2019 № 9 С. 185-192
The article delivers an analysis of German text by the Russian philosopher and classical philologist A.F.Losev (1893–1988) published below which contains four annotations of his earlier works. The author discusses the question of it's dating and shows that the annotations present brief summaries of Losev's treatises which have been later partially used as material for his published books. The treatise ...
Added: September 25, 2019
, Средние века 2012 № 73 (1-2) С. 264-277
The paper deals with the beginning of medieval reception of physiognomics, a specifi c complex of doctrines and knowledge about human body, that, on an individual scale, enabled the adept to judge about what we would call the «character» of an individual. The author analyzes some texts of the 13th century: the «Secret of Secrets» ...
Added: November 19, 2012
, , Stuttgart : Fromann-Holzboog, 2013
Johannes Kepler (1571–1630) spielte als genialer Entdecker von Naturgesetzen eine zentrale Rolle in der frühen Naturphilosophie Schellings und Hegels; die Romantik feierte ihn als Prototypen des Genies schlechthin. Um 1840 setzt sich Schelling in einem veränderten Kontext für die erste Gesamtausgabe der Werke Keplers ein: Die Naturphilosophie wird nun vom Empirismus und Induktivismus scharf kritisiert. ...
Added: September 28, 2013
, Вестник Русской христианской гуманитарной академии 2013 Т. 14 № 3 С. 19-27
The paper deals with the political sense of the dialectical method of Plato. Dialectics is often understood as a pure logical procedure. However the two forms of the dialectical discourse (mentioned in the “Phaedrus”) must be interpreted politically: the first one is a movement of freedom, the second one is a movement of justice. The ...
Added: December 10, 2013
, Философические письма. Русско-европейский диалог 2016 № 3
Arendt becomes famous in the contemporary discourse of the politics. Her concept of the political action, critics of the totalitarian regimes take an important place in the history of political thought in the twentieth century. Arendt refers to the issue of the revolution. In our opinion, she enters into a dispute with the Marx's presentation of ...
Added: December 8, 2015
, , IQ HSE: Research and Education Website 2020
What role has objectivity played in the history of science and what role does it play today? How are innovations in science possible? What is the interrelation between research practices, epistemic virtues, and the scientific self? How are epistemic virtues affected by relations of science and the public, the state, the funders, the industry, media, ...
Added: September 15, 2020
, Логос 2020 Т. 30 № 3 С. 77-98
The heterogeneity of the cybernetics movement, its blurred boundaries, its deep penetration into the scientific, cultural, political and religious institutions of different national communities — all these provide an opening for broadly different approaches to describing the cybernetics movement. Cybernetics was equally attractive to irreconcilable opponents — atheists and clerics, scientists and mystics, Communists and ...
Added: June 30, 2020
, Рацио.ru 2015 № 15 С. 80-96
The purpose of the present paper is to describe and evaluate recent Bayesian developments concerning the theory of confirmation. A special attention is paid to the issues of objectivity and normativity of the Bayesian approach to confirmation of scientific hypotheses by empirical data. It is argued that this approach has, as its main consequence, a ...
Added: January 28, 2016
, В кн. : Наука как общественное благо: Сборник научных статей. Т. 1.: Русское общество истории и философии науки, 2020. С. 74-77.
Одной из важнейших методологических проблем историографии науки является проблема презентизма – искажений, предположительно вносимых в историко-научное исследование при изучении прошлого с точки зрения настоящего. В ходе исследования данной проблемы исследователями были выделены самые различные формы презентизма и антипрезентизма, что затрудняет ее обсуждение. В настоящем докладе рассматривается классификация форм презентизма, предложенная Лораном Луазоном: эмпирический, дескриптивный, каузально-нарративный, ...
Added: November 29, 2020
, История философии 2015 Т. 20 № 1 С. 259-279
Thomas Kuhn has noted that Alexandre Koyré accomplished the local «scientific revolution» by changing the character of the historiography of science. However he should be merited not only by the novelty of approach to the scientific revolution of the 17th century but also by his capacity to mediate between the continental philosophy of the beginning ...
Added: July 16, 2015
Компьютерный поворот в философии XXI в. (Размышления над книгой Йоханнеса Ленхарда «Сюрпризы вычислений. Философия компьютерных симуляций»)
, Вопросы философии 2021 Т. 5 С. 36-46
In 2019, a new book by Lenhard was published. Lenhard attempts to separate computer simulations from classical mathematical modeling. Having structured the material accumulated over the years of research into three parts, Lenhard correctly, without starting the construction of revolutionary metaphysical concepts, takes the reader through the new world of the philosophy of computer simulations. ...
Added: May 19, 2021
, Вопросы философии 2021 № 1 С. 160-171
Historical and philosophical subjects occupied a prominent place in papers of the famous Russian philosopher F.T. Mikhailov. They played the role of methodological guidelines for solving relevant problems of modern humanities.The first part of the article examines the original and undeservedly forgotten solution to the problem of apodictic knowledge proposed by the philosopher. This decision ...
Added: January 23, 2021
, Религиоведческие исследования 2013 № 1-2 С. 155-168
Article is devoted to the history of the study of western esotericism in Western Europe in the twentieth century. Readout of history of academic researches is conducted by the author with the Eranos seminars (Jung, Sholem, Eliade), aft er moving to so called «Yates paradigm», then to former of the fi rst chair in Sorbonne ...
Added: August 22, 2013