Образ Другого в ранней теории воображения М. Мерло-Понти

Философский журнал. 2017. Т. 10. № 1. С. 116–135.

Перцева А. А.

 

Lecture notes of the courses Merleau-Ponty delivered throughout 1950s at Sorbonne and Collège de France give evidence of the rst steps he was taking towards developing, in a polemic with Sartre, his own approach to the problem of imagination. These texts are brought under scrutiny in the present paper, with a special emphasis on the role of the experience of the Other which, in Merleau-Ponty’s analysis, undermines Sartre’s opposition between perception and imagination. The author seeks to demonstrate both the efficiency and the inconsistency of Merleau-Ponty’s early endeavours to criticize Sartre’s theory of the imaginary, tracing down the development of his own approach to imagination starting from the privileged position given to the experience of the Other (which in itself is quite uncharacteristic of Merleau-Ponty’s view of the problem of the Other) as dissolving the boundaries between perception and imagination, and up to the moment when, as a result of his study of Freud, he comes to deny the experience of the Other any privileged status in favour of subordinating its allegedly specific nature to the general principle of perception. The conclusions reached in the course of this inquiry allow to suggest a significant parallel between the privileged place of the Other in Merleau-Ponty’s early critique of Sartre’s doctrine and the motive of the ‘gaze of things’ in his later theory of image. 

 

Keywords: восприятие, воображение, образ, Другой, Жан Поль Сартр, Мерло-Понти, взгляд, ониризм

Similar publications

«И эта тропа священная по земле уходит в небо...»: религиозный натурализм и литургизация природы у М.М. Пришвина

Knorre B. K., Вестник Православного Свято-Тихоновского гуманитарного университета. Серия 1: Богословие. Философия. Религиоведение 2026 № 125 С. 53–69

Orthodoxy, while others, on the contrary, notice a critical attitude towards it, emphasizing that he spent almost all his life in religious search. In our opinion, the answer to the question of assessing Prishvin’s religiosity lies in such a phenomenon as religious naturalism, which is expressed in Prishvin’s religious experience of nature, admitting making natural ...

Added: July 25, 2026

Post-Symbolic Coloniality: The Metasimulacrum of Otherness in Digital Culture

Aliev R. T., Galactica Media: Journal of Media Studies 2025 Vol. 7 No. 2 P. 166– 186

This article develops the concept of the metasimulacrum of otherness to analyze the structural transformations of difference in digital culture. Unlike traditional representations of otherness, the metasimulacrum reorganizes the very conditions of perception, producing otherness as a managed, aestheticized, and commodified flow. Digital platforms no longer marginalize or suppress difference; they integrate it into the ...

Added: July 24, 2026

Proceedings of the International Science Conference “Scientific research of the SCO countries: synergy and integration” - Reports in English (June 3, 2026. Beijing, PRC)

Scientific publishing house Infinity, 2026.

These Conference Proceedings combine materials of the conference – research papers and thesis reports of scientifi c workers. They examine technical, juridical and sociological aspects of research issues. Some articles deal with theoretical and methodological approaches and principles of research questions of personality professionalization. ...

Added: July 24, 2026

Не только ἐπιχώρια διδάγματα: пайдейя Эпаминонда

Mozhaysky A., Schole. Философское антиковедение и классическая традиция 2026 Т. 20 № 2 С. 1105–1116

This article examines the education of Epaminondas, the most famous Theban military and political figure. However, in antiquity, Epaminondas was also renowned for his education and philosophical authority. The study demonstrates that Epaminondas' education encompassed a complex set of local teachings, which Pausanias describes as ἐπιχώρια διδάγματα. However, Epaminondas' education differed from that of most members ...

Added: July 17, 2026

Cognitive Distortions Are Not Logical Errors: A Conceptual Clarification

Denisova V., Petrović N., Journal of Rational - Emotive and Cognitive - Behavior Therapy 2026 Vol. 44 No. 35 P. 1–16

Cognitive distortions are routinely described in cognitive-behavioral (CBT) and rational-emotive behavior (REBT) therapies as “errors in logic” or “illogical thinking.” While this terminology is pedagogically convenient, it often obscures a crucial conceptual distinction between violations of logical inference and problems related to the justification, scope, or evaluative force of belief content. In this paper, we do not ...

Added: July 15, 2026

Возможна ли христианская политика в секулярном мире? С.Н. Булгаков и К. Барт о границах политико-религиозного целеполагания в обществе модерна

Girinsky A., Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология 2026 № 91 С. 104–113

В статье анализируются взгляды двух европейских мыслителей ХХ в. – швейцарского протестантского теолога Карла Барта и русского философа Сергия Булгакова. В центре внимания две их работы середины ХХ в., в которых авторы рассуждают о христианском отношении к государству и политике в мире модерна. В статье доказывается, что несмотря на онтологические и догматические различия между протестантской ...

Added: July 14, 2026

Новые религии и секуляризация. Методологический тупик

Nosachev P., Вопросы философии 2026 № 7 С. 166–175

The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the theoretical foundations of three significant fields: New Religious Movements (NRMs) studies, New Age studies, and Western Esotericism. The author offers a historical overview of these domains, reconstructing the scholarly background and interdisciplinary context of their conceptual formation. It is argued that the primary obstacle to their advancement ...

Added: July 14, 2026

Proceedings of the International Science Conference “APPLIED RESEARCH. GLOBAL SOLUTIONS” (May 6, 2026). Istanbul. Turkey. Part 2.

Scientific publishing house Infinity, 2026.

Science Conference Proceedings combine materials of the conference – research papers and thesis reports of scientifi c workers. They examine technical, juridical and sociological aspects of research issues. Some articles deal with theoretical and methodological approaches and principles of research questions of personality professionalization. ...

Added: July 12, 2026

«Владычествование Homo sapiens над Землей»: утопия или неизбежность?

Grebnev L., Вопросы философии 2026 № 7 С. 5–15

In the coming millennium, the transformation of our world has become a matter of global concern. The first attempts to move in this direction were unsuccessful. The globalization of economic activity is being replaced by the formation of relatively autonomous macroregions. But it would be a mistake to assume on this basis that joint dominion over the entire planet ...

Added: July 11, 2026

Гегель как отец истории искусства: к тезисам Эрнста Гомбриха о пяти гегельянских «великанах»

Жуматина М.-С. Д., Вопросы философии 2026 № 7 С. 140–154

This article analyzes the proclamation of G.W.F. Hegel as the “father of art history” advanced by the art historian E. Gombrich in his essay of the same name, and investigates the origins and consequences of this gesture. The paper examines Gombrich’s arguments concerning fundamental Hegelian ideas – the five Hegelian “giants” – which, in his ...

Added: July 11, 2026

International Academic Conference. Proceedings of the Scientific Forum “Modern Science: Theory and Practice” (April 22, 2026). Belgrade, Serbia. Part 3.

Scientific publishing house Infinity, 2026.

Scientific Forum Proceedings combine materials of the conference – research papers and thesis reports of scientific workers. They examine technical, juridical and sociological aspects of research issues. Some articles deal with theoretical and methodological approaches and principles of research questions of personality professionalization. ...

Added: July 10, 2026

Фронтир семантики и прагматики в философии языка

Sobolev I., Эпистемология и философия науки 2026 Т. 63 № 2 С. 116–134

This article offers a critical analysis of the classical dichotomy between “what is said” and “what is implicated” in philosophy of language. The author argues that a rigid separation between semantics and pragmatics is insufficient to account for the full spectrum of linguistic meaning. Key examples examined include use-conditional meaning, which is conventional yet affects ...

Added: July 9, 2026

Деньги – иллюзорная реальность?

Grebnev L., Вопросы философии 2025 № 6 С. 105–116

The relevance of the topic is related to the fact that after the complete abandonment of real values in the 1970s of the main means of international settlements - the US dollar – there is a growing feeling that money increasingly represents an illusory reality. The article begins with an analysis of the illusions associated ...

Added: July 6, 2026

Моральные дилеммы и дискреция производителей научного и бюрократического знания (Рец. На: Мартыненко А.А. “Бездушные Бюрократы”: Как Устроена Работа Органов Опеки. М.: Фонд Поддержки Социальных Исследований “Хамовники”; Common Place, 2025. 160 С.)

Kuksa T., Этнографическое обозрение 2026 № 4 С. 229–234

Книга Алесандры Мартыненко «“Бездушные бюрократы”: как устроена работа органов опеки» издана в 2025 г. издательством “Common Place” при финансовой поддержке фонда “Хамовники”. Работа выполнена в жанре нарративной этнографии и посвящена анализу профессиональной деятельности и повседневности сотрудников органов опеки и попечительства. Рецензируемый текст отличается глубиной проработки полевого материала и высоким уровнем эмпатии и вовлеченности исследовательницы. Автор успешно применяет метод thick description, создавая эффект живого присутствия и обеспечивая детальную фиксацию эмпирических данных на тактильном, ольфакторном, визуальном и ...

Added: July 3, 2026

Испанский стыд и производство нормы: К аффективной теории социального порядка

Khestanov R., Логос 2026 Т. 36 № 3 С. 1–16

The article proposes an affective theory of social order, taking as its starting point the phenomenon of "Spanish shame" (ispanski styd) – the vicarious embarrassment experienced by a bystander witnessing another person's social failure. Tracing three competing etymological accounts of the expression, the author argues that the uncertainty of its origin is not a defect ...

Added: July 1, 2026

I Международная научно-образовательная конференция «Пейсиковские чтения: проблемы современного академического востоковедения»: материалы конференции

М.: ИСАА МГУ имени М.В. Ломоносова, 2023.

Издание представляет собой сборник материалов I Международной научно-образовательной конференция «Пейсиковские чтения: проблемы современного академического востоковедения», проведённой 21 апреля 2023 года в ИСАА МГУ имени М.В. Ломоносова. В книге представлены работы сотрудников Института и приглашённых специалистов из ряда ведущих институтов России и зарубежных стран Сборник в электронном виде можно скачать по ссылке http://iranistika.iling-ran.ru/Sbornik/ ...

Added: June 30, 2026

Аксиологический разрыв модерна: Иван Иллич об экономических и вернакулярных ценностях после Нового времени

Моторов Д. А., Respublica Literaria 2026 Т. 7 № 2 С. 123–134

The article examines the critical views of the philosopher and social critic Ivan Illich on the beginning of the New Era. Illich's criticism of modernity is based on the consideration of the axiological break of this era, which led to the transformation of the key values of human existence. By contrasting vernacular, that is, locally ...

Added: June 29, 2026

Система синтаксических инвариантов текстовой деятельности: статистические дескрипторы, семантическая структура и диагностические профили

Kudriavtseva E., / РЦИС. Серия № 0148-756-286. 2026.

The content of the work is the system is a system for identifying four types of written speech structures. A set of 11 calculated parameters, statistical standards, and semantic characteristics allows for the identification of a text's structure as the result of a specific cognitive schema (scene, event, story, evaluation). The method has been verified ...

Added: June 2, 2026

Почему растущие доходы не делают людей счастливее: эмоциональное объяснение парадокса Истерлина (Why Growing Incomes Do Not Make People Happier: an Emotional Explanation of the Easterlin Paradox)

Vorchik A., / SSRN. Серия Social Science Research Network "Social Science Research Network". 2026.

This work is devoted to a theoretical explanation of the Easterlin paradox, according to which long-term economic growth does not make average level of people's happiness increasing. By happiness, we mean the intensity of emotions people experience while comparing their new income with its expected value, or the target income with its original value. In the first case, ...

Added: May 31, 2026

Образ и звукозапись: плейлист визуальных мотивов для исследований звука

Nebolsin D., Логос 2026 Т. 36 № 1 С. 113–134

The article addresses the problem of theorizing the relationship between sound and visuality on the material of the more specific topics of recorded sound and visual image. The text is organized as a playlist: throughout the eight sound examples, it identifies the concepts of current image theory that are relevant for theoretical problems of sound ...

Added: May 23, 2026

The interplay of objective fat content and subjective fat perception in determining consumer acceptance of bovine milk

Semenova D., Radygina A., Zaripova J. et al., Nutrition and Food Science 2026 Vol. 56 No. 5 P. 969–981

Purpose This study aims to investigate how objective (chemical composition, processing method) and subjective (perceived fat content) milk characteristics influence taste perception. Design/methodology/approach A blind tasting experiment was conducted with 36 participants who evaluated six commercial milk samples (all 2.5% fat) differing in thermal processing and brand territorial coverage. Each sample was tasted twice, yielding 432 observations. Fatty ...

Added: May 14, 2026

Интерпретация Ф.В.Й. Шеллингом кантовской трансцендентальной аналитики в «Системе трансцендентального идеализма»

Переплеткин А. В., Философия. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2026 Т. 10 № 2 С. 145–167

: The article is dedicated to the core of Critique of Pure Reason, the Transcendental Analytic as it is interpreted by Schelling. Through an analysis of System of Transcenden tal Idealism, it is shown that Schelling’s systematic presentation of Kant’s doctrine is not merely a reordering of its main elements in accordance with the methodical ...

Added: April 29, 2026

Школьный литературный канон эмиграции 1918–1939 гг.

Strizhkova D., / Институт русской литературы (Пушкинский Дом) РАН. Серия B001 "Репозиторий открытых данных по русской литературе и фольклору". 2026.

В базе данных представлена роспись русскоязычных литературных произведений и отрывков, напечатанных в учебниках по словесности, хрестоматиях, книгах для чтения, сборниках стихотворений и рассказов, выходивших во Франции, Германии, Латвии, Эстонии, Болгарии, Сербии в период первой волны русской эмиграции с 1918 по 1939 гг. Датасет представляет интерес для исследователей школьного литературного канона, эмиграции и детского чтения ...

Added: April 22, 2026

«Неизвестный и знакомый»: образ героя в контексте празднования Великой Победы

Жигунов А. Ю., Patria 2025 Т. 2 № 2(6) С. 26–36

In the year of the 80th anniversary of the Great Victory, meanings are interpreted that ensure the dominant position of the celebration of this significant date for Russia and the whole world in the general system of memorable events. The article in interdisciplinary manner analyze the features of the representation of the image of the ...

Added: April 19, 2026