?
Sample Selection Bias in Mortgage Market Credit Risk Modeling
Ch. 16. P. 249–262.
Lozinskaia A. M.
The mortgage crisis that started in the U.S. in 2007 and lasted until 2009 was characterized by an unusually large number of defaults on the subprime mortgage market. As a result, it developed into a global economic recession and placed the stability of the world banking system in jeopardy. Therefore, the issues of credit risk modeling showed the shortcomings of the current credit risk practice. Truncation, or partial observability, and simultaneous equations bias causes sample selection bias. As a result, parameter estimates are biased and inconsistent. Firstly, we provide an overview of current approaches in the mortgage literature to control for the sample selection bias correction, such as the Heckman model and bivariate probit model with selection. Secondly, a review of the most significant mortgage studies discussing this problem is introduced. Specifically, different structural models, specific datasets and empirical results are regarded. In addition, we discuss such key credit risk determinants as borrower characteristics, terms of the mortgage contract, mortgage characteristics, and macroeconomic conditions. Finally, we conclude the discussion with possible research questions.
Keywords: ипотечное кредитованиекредитный рискcredit riskdefaultвероятность дефолтаmortgage lendingsample selectionпроблема самоотбора
Publication based on the results of:
Ozerov K., Кутенко С. В., Деньги и кредит 2024 Т. 83 № 4 С. 98–118
Under limited data, the classical cohort method for the creation of migration matrices does not fully reflect the dynamics of the credit quality of the objects within the sample. This problem is exacerbated for objects of lower credit quality less represented in the sample. This paper investigates a continuous time approach to the creation of ...
Added: December 20, 2025
Галанов В. А., Galanova A., Наука и практика. Научно-аналитический журнал РЭУ им. Г.В. Плеханова 2025 Т. 17 № 1(57) С. 27–34
The differences between short-term and long-term types of investment in the stock market have a deep economic basis in relation to which the time period acts only as a generalizing feature that allows reflecting the holistic and complex range of economic differences between them, primarily in terms of their profitability and risks. The duration of ...
Added: May 28, 2025
Zaiane S., Semenova M., / NRU Higher School of Economics. Series FE "Financial Economics". 2025. No. 96FE2025.
This study examines the relationship between managerial ability (MA) and bank loan quality, employing a quantile regression model. It analyzes whether the impact of MA on loan quality changes across various quantiles of risk. Using a sample of 126 MENA banks (2006–2020), the results reveal that the impact of MA on bank loan quality varies ...
Added: February 18, 2025
Sofiia Dolgikh, Potanin B., Journal of Economic Studies 2026 Vol. 53 No. 1 P. 107–122
The purpose of this study is to empirically investigate gender differences in the returns to different levels of education and studying in STEM fields in Mexico. Specifically, we estimate the effects of education on employment and income. We use data about more than 4.5 m individuals in the year 2020 in Mexico to estimate the average ...
Added: January 31, 2025
Sizykh D., Kovalev R., Sizykh N., , in: 2024 17th International Conference on Management of Large-Scale System Development (MLSD).: IEEE, 2024. P. 1–5.
To improve the assessment model of credit risk by Merton for Russian financial market using the Monte Carlo simulation method and the SARIMA model for data forecasting. Nowadays, there are many methods of the assessment use in European countries. However, the applications of these methods may lead to inaccurate forecasts. In this work, modern methods ...
Added: January 15, 2025
Galanova A., Овсяник В. А., Наука и практика. Научно-аналитический журнал РЭУ им. Г.В. Плеханова 2024 Т. 16 № 3(55) С. 37–50
Credit ratings represent an assessment of the totality of borrowers' risks, and due to the very method of compilation, they contain a large amount of information about companies which is taken into account by market participants. The impact of news release about a change in a company's credit rating on the dynamics of its stock prices can be analyzed ...
Added: December 21, 2024
Afanasev V., Финансы и бизнес 2024 Vol. 20 No. 3 P. 71–88
The conventional approach to default prediction implies using financial ratios as predictors. This paper provides evidence for improvement in the quality of default prediction for auto repair firms if non-financial data is included in the models. The study uses a sample of more than 200 firms, which defaulted in 2018–2023 and 10 healthy peers samples ...
Added: October 2, 2024
Penikas H. I., / Банк России. Серия доклады Банка России "Серия докладов об экономических исследованиях". 2024.
In 2016, the Bank of Russia developed two ordinances to set forth a procedure using a limited sample of loans to conclude whether the level of loss provisions in the portfolio of uniform loans is sufficient or not and whether the bank’s capital is adequate.
The existing procedure of reserve sufficiency evaluation previews as a rule considering only a part of the loan portfolio and transfer (extrapolation) of the provision thus assessed for the overall portfolio. Moreover, the acting approach to define the minimum loan sample size assumes the absence of the default correlation.
Author’s contribution ...
Added: June 1, 2024
Pomazanov M. V., Бережной А. Д., Риск-менеджмент в кредитной организации 2023 № 4(52) С. 6–14
Кредитоспособность заемщиков существенно различается от региона к региону, при этом построить скоринговую модель для каждого региона невозможно. Для калибровки скоринговых моделей с учетом региона необходимо учесть макроэкономиче- ские факторы, оказывающие влияние на вероятность дефолта (PD). Какими могут быть подходы к построению макроэкономи- ческих моделей для получения прогнозов вероятности дефолта в регионах? Как использовать метод ...
Added: February 8, 2024
Penikas H. I., Вопросы экономики 2023 Т. 6 С. 36–61
Впервые рассмотрен уникальный массив данных о предложении ставок по кредитам с февраля по август 2022 г. Обосновано, что такие предложения, содержащие информацию о ставке и дополнительных условиях (срок, сумма и т. д.), чаще дают более крупные банки. Проанализированы слагаемые как кредитного риска ссуды, так и риск-аппетита банка. Показано, что банки, оценивающие кредитный риск для нормативов ...
Added: June 9, 2023
Маракуева М. А., Финансы и бизнес 2021 Т. 17 № 4 С. 3–17
The article discusses the most common mistakes in banking practice when constructing scoring models for assessing the credit risk of individuals. For a detail description, we have selected the most significant ones from the point of view of generating retail profit. With the example of logistic regression we show how much the price of each ...
Added: April 8, 2023
Dolgikh S., Potanin B., Проблемы прогнозирования 2023 № 3 С. 146–157
The study is devoted to the analysis of dividend policy of Russian firms. This policy is considered as a two-step process. First, firm makes a decision whether to pay dividends. Second, it decides how much to pay. To estimate the influence of various factors on these decisions we have proposed a two-step estimation procedure that ...
Added: January 11, 2023
Kuzmina E., Фирак А. Е., Финансы и бизнес 2022 Т. 18 № 3 С. 62–72
This article will consider the impact of various socio-demographic factors on the real estate market in the regions of Russia. As an indicator reflecting changes in the real estate market, the volume of mortgage lending was chosen. Based on the use of panel data and a fixed effects model, the study concluded that the proportion ...
Added: December 21, 2022
Pomazanov M. V., Риск-менеджмент в кредитной организации 2022 Т. 48 № 4 С. 31–39
Описанный подход к валидации риск-менеджмента розничного портфеля применялся в крупнейших банках и дал безупречно обоснованный результат, ускоривший коррекцию риск-политик в существенных сегментах розничных продуктов вплоть до закрытия одних и расширения планов размещения других. На основе оценки экономической выгоды от усиления риск-менеджмента с учетом текущих и плановых объемов могут быть обоснованно увеличены бюджеты на расширение аналитического ...
Added: December 20, 2022
Khasyanova S. Y., Вопросы статистики 2022 Т. 29 № 5 С. 96–109
The purpose of this study is to investigate how the Covid-19 pandemic affected the stability of Russian banks .To achieve this goal, an economic and statistical analysis of the risk and liquidity indicators of the Russian banking sector for the period 2008-2020 was performed. The analysis was based on the methodology for assessing the financial ...
Added: November 24, 2022
Pomazanov M. V., , in: The 8th International Conference on Information Technology and Quantitative Management (ITQM 2020 & 2021): Developing Global Digital Economy after COVID-19Vol. 199: The 8th International Conference on Information Technology and Quantitative Management (ITQM 2020 & 2021): Developing Global Digital Economy after COVID-19.: Manchester: Elsevier, 2022. P. 798–805.
The article considers the issue of quantifying the quality of discrimination (approval) in the retail portfolio segments based on current statistical data on the level of refuse of customers who applied to the bank, the current level of defaults and market data (credit history bureaus). The analysis of the economic efficiency of the practiced level ...
Added: November 18, 2022
Цехомский Н. В., Наумцева Е. И., Кудлай В. А. et al., Банковское дело 2022 № 9 С. 30–38
Статья посвящена анализу развития рынка синдицированного кредитования в Российской Федерации и исследованию практических аспектов применения нового инструмента российского вторичного рынка синдицированного кредитования – финансирования участия в кредите (займе). Установление правовых основ в отношении такого нового механизма и расширение палитры инструментов вторичного рынка, доступных участникам российских сделок синдицированного кредитования, создало потенциал для дальнейшего развития отечественного рынка синдицированного ...
Added: November 14, 2022
Ivanova N. S., Penikas H. I., Popova S. et al., Деньги и кредит 2022 Т. 81 № 3 С. 89–106
In early July 2022, the Bank of Russia and the New Economic School held a joint workshop titled ‘Transition to a Low-Carbon Economy: Costs and Risks for the Financial Sector’. The presentations delivered at the workshop enable a number of general conclusions to be drawn. First, as follows from the results of the calculations in ...
Added: October 13, 2022
Kossova E. V., Potanin B., Прикладная эконометрика 2022 № 3(67) С. 121–143
We propose a two-step estimation procedure for multinomial endogenous switching model assuming joint normality of random errors. Simulated data analysis suggests that our method outperforms popular alternatives when independence of irrelevant alternatives (IIA) assumption is violated. We also apply our method to estimate marriage male premium. We have found statistical evidence that this premium is ...
Added: October 5, 2022
Iakimenko I., Semenova M., Zimin E., Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 2022 Vol. 80 Article 101651
Estimating correctly the borrower credit risks is the task of particular –and growing- importance for the banks all around the globe. Formal information sharing mechanisms are aimed to reduce information asymmetry in the credit markets and to enhance the precision of those estimates. In the academic literature, however, the answer to the question of whether ...
Added: September 15, 2022