Mutual recognition: A dialogue between Italian and Russian perspectives

Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Philosophy and Conflict Studies. 2020. Vol. 36. No. 1. P. 141–156.

Pirni A., Nikolaeva Z., Sofia V. Ignateva

The knowledge and understanding of kaleidoscopic and hypermodern societies rely heavily  on the term “recognition.” This term carried a great deal of significance in the Russian philosophical tradition, but attracts less attention now. The main purpose of this paper is to offer  a contribution to the discussion on this topic, by considering both the Russian and the European philosophical traditions, with specific reference to the Italian perspective. The methodological focus is concerned with the two essential aspects of recognition: that of the interpersonal and that of the group. Our philosophical analysis of recognition endeavors to take into  account first and foremost the problematic field of Otherness. The process of recognition of  the Other is thus considered according to three stages of approval: cognitive, moral and social.  Cognitive approval includes the identification of the Other as opposite to the group as well as to each individual. The moral stage contemplates concretization of social objectives and accepting the Other as a whole that should above all be respected and accepted. At the stage of  social approval, the individual is being recognized within the social context of a group (closed social group) as recognition or rejection. Specifying the recognition leads to a reduction in the number of conflicts, the clarification of borders, and the acceptance of Otherness as an element of individuality. The contribution to the theory of recognition here outlined is new to the Russian scientific context, and may prove challenging in the context of Russian-Italian  dialogue. It also constitutes an attempt to compare the common representations of Otherness with current theoretical developments. The theory is illustrated by analysis of closed social groups functioning as a promising series of case studies, in order to open up a renewed interest in research into social reality theories in both Russian and Italian contexts.

Keywords: идентичность, identity, recognition, принятие, Другой, признание, Other, Acceptance, Закрытые социальные группы