Адаптация международного опыта защиты вещных прав в российской правовой системе: на примере Франции

Вопросы российского и международного права. 2024. Т. 14. № 9-1. С. 323–329.

Ноздрина Н. А., Yagunova E. E.

This article analyzes modern Russian practice in the field of ensuring property rights and legal possession. In order to improve the regulation of property rights, it is necessary to search for ways to improve the mechanism for protecting property rights and legal ownership through the study of law enforcement practices. At the same time, unlike the currently widespread approach in the scientific literature, which is focused on evaluating statistical indicators, such as, for example, the proportion of satisfied claims of applicants for infringement of property rights, it is necessary to apply analysis tools aimed at identifying the motivation of the judicial authority when making a decision contained in the relevant judicial decision. the act. The use of this tool is more significant compared to the search for a new paradigm for the protection of property rights and legitimate authority based on legal models used in developed countries. As a result of the analysis of law enforcement practice, it has been revealed that incorrect interpretations by courts of the categories of property law and lawful possession lead to restrictions on their provision and create precedents that may eventually become the basis for the development of new types of fraud with property rights and lawful possession rights.

Keywords: право собственности, имущественные отношения, вещные права, законное владение, обеспечение вещных прав