• A
  • A
  • A
  • АБВ
  • АБВ
  • АБВ
  • A
  • A
  • A
  • A
  • A
Обычная версия сайта
  • RU
  • EN
  • HSE University
  • Publications
  • Articles
  • «Смысл нам спорить»: оценка целесообразности вступления в спор
  • RU
  • EN
Расширенный поиск
Высшая школа экономики
Национальный исследовательский университет
Priority areas
  • business informatics
  • economics
  • engineering science
  • humanitarian
  • IT and mathematics
  • law
  • management
  • mathematics
  • sociology
  • state and public administration
by year
  • 2027
  • 2026
  • 2025
  • 2024
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2008
  • 2007
  • 2006
  • 2005
  • 2004
  • 2003
  • 2002
  • 2001
  • 2000
  • 1999
  • 1998
  • 1997
  • 1996
  • 1995
  • 1994
  • 1993
  • 1992
  • 1991
  • 1990
  • 1989
  • 1988
  • 1987
  • 1986
  • 1985
  • 1984
  • 1983
  • 1982
  • 1981
  • 1980
  • 1979
  • 1978
  • 1977
  • 1976
  • 1975
  • 1974
  • 1973
  • 1972
  • 1971
  • 1970
  • 1969
  • 1968
  • 1967
  • 1966
  • 1965
  • 1964
  • 1963
  • 1958
  • More
Subject
News
November 17, 2026
Physicists Show How a Solvent Shapes the Response of Drug Molecules
Many drug molecules can switch between different three-dimensional shapes. Using a mathematical model of ibuprofen dissolved in supercritical CO₂, researchers from HSE University and the Institute of Solution Chemistry of the Russian Academy of Sciences have shown that the solvent can make these molecules appear to respond unusually slowly. The molecules themselves continue to change shape rapidly, but their surroundings rearrange much more slowly, and this lag shows up in the measurements. The study has been published in The Journal of Chemical Physics. 
November 10, 2026
Physicists Train AI to Optimise Particle Beams in Accelerators
Researchers from the AI and Digital Science Institute at the HSE Faculty of Computer Science and the Budker Institute of Nuclear Physics at the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences have developed RLABC (Reinforcement Learning for Accelerator Beamline Control), a framework that uses reinforcement learning to identify optimal settings for a particle accelerator. In a computer simulation, RLABC optimised the accelerator's parameters to achieve a particle transmission rate of 70%. The study has been published in Computer Physics Communications.
November 9, 2026
'Organ-on-a-Chip Technology Could Eliminate the Need for Animal Testing'
The Laboratory of Molecular Physiology at the HSE Faculty of Biology and Biotechnology investigates how molecular regulators known as microRNAs control gene expression and contribute to the development of diseases, including cancer, viral and inflammatory conditions, and pregnancy complications. At HSE University, researchers develop organ-on-a-chip models: miniature devices containing living cells that mimic the functions of human organs, such as the placenta and intestines. These models help researchers understand how diseases develop and how drugs affect them. HSE News Service spoke with Evgeny Knyazev, Head of the Laboratory.

 

Have you spotted a typo?
Highlight it, click Ctrl+Enter and send us a message. Thank you for your help!

Publications
  • Books
  • Articles
  • Chapters of books
  • Working papers
  • Report a publication
  • Research at HSE

?

«Смысл нам спорить»: оценка целесообразности вступления в спор

Вестник Московского университета. Серия 7: Философия. 2025. Т. 49. № 1. С. 107–124.
Mikirtumov I., Фролов К. Г.

This study has two aims. First, we present several types of reasons that determine whether it is appropriate for an agent to enter into the dispute. Second, we propose a way to compare these reasons depending on several parameters. This allows the agent to make a justified decision to enter into the or not. The types of
reasons we have identified are: the priority of achieving certain direct or indirect goals of the dispute; the character of the deliberation (competitive or communitarian); strength of the agent’s position; the ratio of the importance for the agent of subjective motives and objective reasons; a set of available argumentative strategies in a dispute; free or forced character of the dispute; discursive mode of the dispute; level of communicative competence of the agent. At the first stage of assessment, each of the available strategies is assessed taking into account its contribution to the
achievement of certain direct or indirect goals of the dispute. This assessment also accounts two other parameters: the strength of the agent’s position and the character of deliberation. At the second stage, this assessment is adjusted taking into account the parameters of the discursive regime of the dispute and the ability of the agent
to change this regime. 

Research target: Philosophy, Ethics, and Religious Studies
Language: Russian
Full text
DOI
Text on another site
Keywords: аргументацияargumentationдискурсивный режимDeliberationделиберацияdiscursive regimenormative foundationscommunitarian disputetertiary disputeнормативные основаниякоммунитарный спортертиартный спор
Similar publications
Внедрение искусственного интеллекта в политическую деятельность:постановка проблемы
Sannikova E., Внутских А. Ю., Вестник Пермского университета. Философия. Психология. Социология 2026 № 2 С. 222–234
The article presents a social-philosophical analysis of the fundamental contradiction between the declared ideals of artificial intelligence (AI) integration into political activity and the actual, largely spontaneous process of digitalization in this sphere. The relevance of the study is driven by the fact that AI technolo gies are increasingly penetrating the domains of public administration, electoral processes, political ...
Added: November 16, 2026
Джаяраши Бхатта. Таттвопаплавасимха. Глава I. Фрагменты M 6a – M 12b / Пер. с санскрита и примеч. Н.А. Канаевой
Kanaeva N., Вопросы философии 2026 № 11 С. 130–140
The presented translation of a fragment of Jayarāśi Bhatta’s (8th–9th centuries) enigmatic work Tattvopaplavasiṁha (“The Lion, [Overturning] Obstacles [to the Correct Understanding] of Categories”] discusses the problem of  universals. The article offers an interpretation of the medieval Indian philosophers’ debate on the problem of universals. The interpretation was based on the concepts that are explicit in the authoritative school texts ...
Added: November 15, 2026
Florenskij, Schelling e il culto milesio di Poseidone. Uno scorcio cosmo-teogonico del pensiero di Talete
Dezi A., Rivista di Filosofia Neo-Scolastica 2021 Vol. 113 No. 1 P. 225–246
This paper analyses the influence of Schelling’s thought on a peculiar thesis about the origin of western philosophy expounded by P.A. Florensky during a course of lectures, First Steps of Philosophy, held at Moscow Theological Academy in 1909. Nourished by the lively Russian culture of the early 20th century, Florensky’s thesis, «philosophy was born of ...
Added: November 15, 2026
Primi passi della filosofia. Lezioni sull'origine della filosofia occidentale
Florenskij P., Sesto San Giovanni: Mimesis, 2021.
In 1909, at the Moscow Theological Academy, Pavel A. Florensky delivered a series of lectures entitled First Steps of Philosophy. In 1917, he published a volume in Sergiev Posad under the same title, containing a reworking of part of the course. The present Italian edition brings together the writings published in 1917 and the manuscript ...
Added: November 14, 2026
«La più nobile delle cose è l’acqua». Schelling e Florenskij sulla radice cosmo-teogonica del pensiero filosofico
Dezi A., Critical Hermeneutics 2024 Vol. 7 No. 2 P. 151–186
In a series of lectures delivered in 1909 at the Moscow Theological Academy, Florensky presented an audacious thesis: philosophy – he claimed – was born of the worship of the god Poseidon. Significant aspects of Russian and European culture converge in the fervent scientific, philosophical, artistic, and religious terrain from which the thesis stems. Among ...
Added: November 14, 2026
Il «νοῦς βασιλικός» in Philebus 30d e l’idea schellinghiana di una libera causa
Dezi A., Rivista di Filosofia Neo-Scolastica 2021 Vol. 113 No. 2 P. 535–560
Schelling’s assiduous reflection on Plato’s Philebus runs throughout all his work. It is imprinted in its essential theoretical articulations. The notion of «noûs basilikós», in particular, deeply marks Schelling’s positive conception of a «true Cause of all real being». This essay focuses on that conception, considered in its first branching from the Platonic root. In ...
Added: November 14, 2026
Нас не заменят, или о трансформации креативного производства в условиях генеративного ИИ
Fadeeva T., Креативные индустрии 2026 Т. 2 № 1 (5) С. 10–22
Abstract. The article examines the impact of generative artificial intelligence technologies on creative industries within the framework of media theory and philosophy of technology. The theoretical foundation of the study includes Marshall McLuhan’s concepts of medial “extensions,” Bernard Stiegler’s and David Wills’ prosthetic logic of technology, as well as contemporary empirical studies of the creative ...
Added: November 14, 2026
«Die Potenzen und das Potenzlose». Note sulla quadruplice struttura del Reale nel Sistema schellinghiano di Würzburg
Dezi A., Rivista di Filosofia Neo-Scolastica 2022 Vol. 114 No. 3 P. 681–698
In the following Notes, the Author will investigate the relationship between «Potenzen» and «Potenzlosen» in Schelling’s Würzburger System. In particular, he will study 1) the relationship of the Absolute (or God) with the potencies; 2) the phenomenal appearance of the «Potenzlosen»; 3) the possibility of «representing» a «divine Identity», as opposed to a finite one. ...
Added: November 14, 2026
Sistema dell'intera filosofia e della filosofia della natura in particolare
Schelling F. W., Sesto San Giovanni: Mimesis, 2023.
The first complete Italian translation of F. W. J. Schelling's System of Philosophy in General and of the Philosophy of Nature in Particular (1804), also known as the Würzburg System. The work offers one of Schelling's most systematic presentations of his philosophy of identity, integrating the real and ideal dimensions of philosophy, philosophy of nature, ...
Added: November 14, 2026
ЛИКИ ДЗЭН - японские классики Дзэн-буддизма
Dolin A., Издательский Дом "Наука", 2026.
A collection of Zen-buddhist poetic texts with  an Introductionm academic commentaries and biographic notes. ...
Added: November 12, 2026
XXVIII Елисаветинско-Сергиевские чтения. Москва в царствование императоров Александра III и Николая II. По материалам выставки «Августейший хозяин Москвы»
М.: Елисаветинско-Сергиевское просветительское общество, 2026.
Сборник включает материалы XXVIII Елизаветинско-Сергиевских чтений, состоявшихся в Москве 1 ноября 2025 г., посвящённых 180-летию со дня рождения императора Александра III и 120-летию памяти великого князя Сергея Александровича, и завершающих культурную и научно-просветительскую программу выставки «Августейший хозяин Москвы» (организованной Фондом «Елизаветинско-Сергиевское просветительское общество» в Музее Москвы в июле — ноябре 2025 г.). Сборник предназначен для историков, ...
Added: November 8, 2026
Авторские теории творчества
Касаткина Т. А., Корбелла К., Сергеева В. С. et al., М.: ИМЛИ РАН, 2025.
В книге ставится задача описать ряд имплицитных авторских теорий творчества, вскрываемых анализом текстов и подтверждаемых эксплицитными высказываниями автора, в том числе такими, которые могут на неискушенный взгляд совсем не относится ни к каким авторским "теориям", высказываниям словно совсем о другом - но вскрывающими сердцевину авторского мировидения и, соответственно, главные принципы его творчества. ...
Added: November 6, 2026
Философия истории Ивана Иллича: томистские основания критики модерна
Моторов Д. А., История философии 2026 Т. 31 № 1 С. 56–69
The article examines the “weak” philosophy of the history of the social critic and philosopher Ivan Illich, which is based on the author’s reinterpretation of Thomas Aquinas’ analogia entis, which occurred under the influence of Illich’s acquaintance and friendship with a prominent representative of neo-Thomism Jacques Maritain. In Ivan Illich’s philosophy, analogia entis turns into ...
Added: November 5, 2026
Кризис секулярности в трансмедийной вселенной «Игры престолов»
Shteynman M. A., Studia Religiosa Rossica: научный журнал о религии 2024 № 2 С. 156–171
Social reality of the “Game of Thrones” is considered in this article not as a model or a kind of reconstruction of Middle Ages reality. On the contrary we argue that “Game of Thrones” as well as original “Song of Ice and Fire” should be studied through the prism of social and cultural trens of the 20th – beginning ...
Added: November 5, 2026
Extraordinary, Power, Chaos, and Spirits: Taxonomy of Mysteries in Samguk sagi 三國史記
Alexander V. Solovyov, Journal of Sinographic Philologies and Legacies 2026 Vol. 2 No. 3 P. 107–144
This article seeks to redefine the Kim Pusik’s 金富軾 (1075-1151) Samguk sagi 三國史記 (Histories of the Three Kingdoms) as a more imaginative and literary text by foregrounding its “supernatural” elements (collectively referred to as “wonder tales”), rather than emphasizing the ‘Confucian’ orientation that has conventionally been prescribed to it. It reviews the extend of incorporation ...
Added: November 3, 2026
Vague Stimulating Ideas, Images and Metaphors in Scientific Thinking: Researchers’ Work with Horizons of Unclear Knowledge
Poddiakov A., Integrative Psychological and Behavioral Science 2026 Vol. 60 No. 4 P. 1–50
Clarity of knowledge and reasoning is necessary in many cases. Yet vagueness in scientific thinking related to surprise, curiosity, and “ability to engage with not-knowing” (de Freitas) is also a crucially important source of scientific creativity. Starting from studies by C. S. Peirce and B. Russell, scientists have developed tools for working with increasingly accurate ...
Added: November 3, 2026
Имплицитное обучение аргументации на занятиях по английскому языку с опорой на таксономию Блума
Voronina Y., Kuryan M., Педагогика и психология образования 2026 № 2 С. 84–98
Teaching argumentation in foreign language classes is a promising approach, as it enhances students' critical thinking and improves the quality of their academic work. Despite the rather widespread use of explicit methods for developing argumentation skills, the implicit approach remains underexplored. This paper proposes a system for organizing implicit argumentation instruction in English based on ...
Added: August 24, 2026
Жанровый подход как способ повышения эффективности обучения аргументации на английском языке.
Kuryan M., Voronina Y., Нижегородское образование 2026 № 1 С. 61–68
The article addresses the problem of developing English argumentation skills among Russian-speaking students. Now that modern education places an emphasis on the development of complex cognitive skills argumentative competence has become a key element of successful academic communication. However, Russian-speaking learners face certain difficulties in mastering this type of competence within the English-language educational context. The ...
Added: April 11, 2026
Князь Владимир выбирает православие, или Три спора в «Сказании об испытании вер»
Lisanyuk E., Философский журнал 2026 Т. 19 № 1 С. 147–162
We apply five classifications of argumentative dialogues to the three disputes in the “Tale of the Test of Faith” from the ‘Tale of Bygone Years’ for demonstrating their contribution to solving key problems of argumentation analysis – its detection, reconstruction and evaluation. We employ the classifications of Aristotle, S.I. Povarnin, E. Krabbe and D. Walton, ...
Added: April 1, 2026
Особенности стратегии убеждения в российском и китайском политическом дискурсе (на материале политических ток-шоу «60 минут» и «这就是中国» («Это Китай»))
Бинштейн М. М., Вестник Томского государственного университета. Филология 2026 № 99 С. 5–27
The article explores the argumentative nature of political discourse, which, according to the authors, becomes the key to the analysis of the communicativestrategy of persuasion. The aim of the research is a comparative analysis of speeches by Russian and Chinese politicians, identifying similarities and differences in the use of rhetorical devices when implementing the persuasion ...
Added: March 19, 2026
Ретрибутивные эмоции и ретрибутивные интуиции
Faul B., Галактика медиа: журнал медиа исследований 2025 Т. 7 № 4 С. 174 – 197
The article addresses a key challenge to moral justification in normative ethics - the relationship between emotions and retributive moral judgments. Retributivism holds that there are normative reasons to reward or punish individuals on the basis of merit, independent of consequences. A common objection argues that such beliefs are grounded in retributive emotions, which are ...
Added: January 27, 2026
17th International Conference, SCSM 2025, Held as Part of the 27th HCI International Conference, HCII 2025, Gothenburg, Sweden, June 22–27, 2025, Proceedings, Part II. Social Computing and Social Media. LNCS, volume 15787
Fedyanin D., Switzerland: Springer, 2025.
The 17th International Conference on Social Computing and Social Media (SCSM 2025) was an affiliated conference of the HCI International (HCII) conference. It provided an established international forum for the exchange and dissemination of scientific information related to social computing and social media, addressing a broad spectrum of issues expanding our understanding of current and future issues in ...
Added: December 3, 2025
Функции визуализации в программном обеспечении для репрезентации аргументации
Прокудин Д. Э., Lisanyuk E., Баымуратов И. Р., Научная визуализация 2024 Т. 16 № 3 С. 106–122
In the historical development of argumentation as a scientific direction and applied field, a number of ways of its visual representation have been developed. In the middle of the 20th century, within the framework of the theory of argumentation, in addition to the logical, rhetorical and computational concepts used since ancient times, new concepts were ...
Added: October 1, 2024
Демонстративные аргументы в логике устранения одной юридической коллизии
Lisanyuk E., Философия. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2024 Т. 8 № 1 С. 67–80
Submitted: Dec. 18, 2023. Reviewed: Dec. 30, 2023. Accepted: Jan. 11, 2024. Abstract: Based on modern approaches to defining critical thinking, we identify three of its properties — thoroughness, proactivity and heuristic suitability, associated with solving preference tasks, in contrast to demonstrative argumentation in solving logical tasks. Through the example of eliminating a legal collision ...
Added: June 5, 2024
  • About
  • About
  • Key Figures & Facts
  • Sustainability at HSE University
  • Faculties & Departments
  • International Partnerships
  • Faculty & Staff
  • HSE Buildings
  • HSE University for Persons with Disabilities
  • Public Enquiries
  • Studies
  • Admissions
  • Programme Catalogue
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Exchange Programmes
  • Summer University
  • Summer Schools
  • Semester in Moscow
  • Business Internship
  • Research
  • International Laboratories
  • Research Centres
  • Research Projects
  • Monitoring Studies
  • Conferences & Seminars
  • Academic Jobs
  • Yasin (April) International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development
  • Media & Resources
  • Publications by staff
  • HSE Journals
  • Publishing House
  • iq.hse.ru: commentary by HSE experts
  • Library
  • Economic & Social Data Archive
  • Video
  • HSE Repository of Socio-Economic Information
  • HSE1993–2026
  • Contacts
  • Copyright
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Map
Edit