Positional Voting Methods Satisfying the Criteria of Weak Mutual Majority and Condorcet Loser

Automation and Remote Control. 2018. Vol. 79. No. 8. P. 1489–1514.

A. Yu. Kondratev

This paper considers a voting problem in which the individual preferences of electors are defined by the ranked lists of candidates. For single-winner elections, we apply the criterion of weak positional dominance (WPD, PD), which is closely related to the positional scoring rules. Also we formulate the criterion of weak mutual majority (WMM), which is stronger than the majority criterion but weaker than the criterion of mutual majority (MM). Then we construct two modifications for the median voting rule that satisfy the Condorcet loser criterion. As shown below, WPD and WMM are satisfied for the first modification while PD and MM for the second modification. We prove that there is no rule satisfying WPD and MM simultaneously. Finally, we check a list of 37 criteria for the constructed rules.

Ключевые слова: правило большинства, Voting rules, mutual majority, majority criterion, совместное большинство, правило голосования

ПУБЛИКАЦИЯ ПОДГОТОВЛЕНА ПО РЕЗУЛЬТАТАМ ПРОЕКТА: Дизайн экономических механизмов: современные подходы (2018)