?
Red Patriots against White Patriots: Contesting Patriotism in the Civil War in North Russia
Europe-Asia Studies. 2019. Vol. 71. No. 2. P. 183-202.
Novikova L.
This article uses the example of Arkhangel’sk province in North Russia to examine how the two main parties in the Russian Civil War—the Bolsheviks and the White armies—used elements of nationalism and xenophobia to delegitimise their enemies. It reveals the evolution of patriotic rhetoric, first used by the Whites to discredit the Bolsheviks as German agents, and then by the Reds to delegitimise the Whites as agents of the Entente. In the 1920s anti-Allied sentiments became the main trope in the memory of the civil war both among émigrés and in the Soviet North.
Keywords: патриотизмRussian Civil Warnationalismбелое движениеГражданская война в Россииpatriotismthe Red ArmyКрасная армияWhite movementимперский национализмПервая мировая войнаFirst World War
Publication based on the results of:
Yakovenko V., Новое прошлое 2018 № 1 С. 268-274
In 2017 the second edition of the monograph of the historian A.V. Ganin “Everyday Life of the General Staff Officers under Lenin and Trotsky” was published. This book is the result of the long standing research done by Ganin. The book was highly appreciated by specialists. The proposed review gives an analysis of the positive ...
Added: April 12, 2019
Novikova L., М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2011
В глазах многих современников и историков российской Гражданской войны Белое движение было делом прежних имперских элит, не понявших и не принявших революцию. Белые желали вернуть прежнюю Россию. Это подчеркивал и возвышенный цветаевский образ «белогвардейской рати святой», и совсем не поэтичная белая «контрреволюция», о которой писали советские историки. Но к чему в действительности стремились белые правительства? ...
Added: March 11, 2013
Liudmila G. Novikova, Europe-Asia Studies 2008 Vol. 60 No. 2 P. 277-293
This article examines popular participation in the anti-bolshevik movement in Arkhangel’sk province
of the Russian North during the first months of the Civil War. Using the example of local
administration, mobilisation and bread supply it demonstrates how the particularities of the revolution
in the province influenced the growth of the White movement and how people were able partly ...
Added: December 20, 2013
Ljudmila Novikova, Osteuropa 2014 Vol. 64 No. 2-4 P. 157-170
The Archangelsk Governorate was only a fraction of the European front during the First World War. But this ostensibly marginal region is representative for Russia. Neither the year 1917 nor the year 1918 represented a turning point. The First World War, the Revolution, and the Civil War were so tightly interwoven that contemporaries saw these ...
Added: April 11, 2014
Novikova, Ljudmila G., Rivista Storica Italiana 2012 Vol. 124 No. 2 P. 734-763
This article analyzes grass-root politics in the Russian Civil War, challenging the traditional assumption that the Bolsheviks with their program of radical revolutionary change enjoyed greater popularity than their White adversaries. On the example of the Northern region, it demonstrates that the local «counter-revolutionary» government commanded considerable sympathies of the provincial population. This popularity was ...
Added: March 18, 2013
Liudmila G. Novikova, Europe-Asia Studies 2013 Vol. 65 No. 9 P. 1755-1770
This essay re-examines White and Red terror during the Russian Civil War by studying public participation in the acts of political violence. It shifts attention from the ideological and political motifs of terror to places and contexts where violence occurred. On the example of paramilitary groups of White and Red partisans in Arkhangel’sk province in ...
Added: September 27, 2013
Novikova Ljudmila, Cahiers du Monde Russe 2017 Т. 58 № 1-2 С. 95-122
The article examines the political and administrative functions of the zemstvos in Arkhangel´sk province in northern Russia during the Civil War. Zemstvos were liquidated in the province in early 1918 after the Bolsheviks’ seizure of power, but later resumed their work under the anti‑Bolshevik Provisional Government of Northern Russia between mid‑1918 and 1920. The reinstated ...
Added: July 31, 2017
Novikova L., University of Wisconsin Press, 2018
The traditional narrative of the Russian Civil War is one of revolution against counterrevolution, Bolshevik Reds against Tsarist Whites. Liudmila Novikova convincingly demonstrates, however, that the struggle was not between a Communist future and a Tsarist past; instead, it was a bloody fight among diverse factions of a modernizing postrevolutionary state. Focusing on the sparsely ...
Added: May 31, 2018
Sunderland W., Cornell University Press, 2014
In The Baron's Cloak, Willard Sunderland tells the epic story of the Russian Empire's final decades through the arc of the Baron's life, which spanned the vast reaches of Eurasia. Tracking Ungern's movements, he transits through the Empire's multinational borderlands, where the country bumped up against three other doomed empires, the Habsburg, Ottoman, and Qing, and where the violence unleashed by war, revolution, and imperial ...
Added: November 9, 2018
Sablin I., Vestnik Sankt-Peterburgskogo Universiteta, Istoriya 2017 Vol. 62 No. 1 P. 18-25
Three major factions in the Russian Civil War in the Far East engaged in nationalist mobilization coming up with different rhetorical tropes and images in the 1920-1922 period. The ultra-royalist faction led by Mikhail Konstantinovich Diterikhs, which in 1922 controlled the Provisional Priamur Government in Vladivostok, portrayed the Romanovs as redeemers who had ended the ...
Added: April 4, 2017
Sablin I., Ab imperio 2017 No. 1 P. 402-406
Jonathan D. Smele’s comprehensive account fits well into the prolonged centenary of the Russian imperial crisis marked by the Great War, the Russian Revolution of 1917, and the protracted conflict that the author calls the “‘Russian’ Civil Wars.” The book is a valuable addition to the new body of literature that will, hopefully, bring about ...
Added: June 21, 2017
М. : МПГУ, 2015
В сборнике собраны статьи участников юбилейной конференции «ХХ Шешуковские чтения». В центре научной проблематики конфе- ренции — военная тема в отечественной словесности: философские и историософские основы осмысления военных событий в литературном тексте, формирование традиций изображения войны в русской литерату- ре, этико-эстетические поиски в литературе о войне, современные лите- ратурные и журналистские подходы к прочтению военной ...
Added: October 20, 2016
Novikova L., , in : Russia’s Home Front in War and Revolution, 1914-22. Vol. 1: Russia’s Revolution in Regional Perspective.: Bloomington : Slavica Publishers, 2015. P. 87-108.
This chapter discusses peasant political attitudes during the Russian Revolution and Civil War on the example of their interaction with zemstvos. Focusing on the zemstvo self-government in Arkhangel’sk province in the Russian North between 1917 and early 1920, it tells two interconnected stories: an institutional story of the Northern zemstvo during the Revolution and Civil ...
Added: November 28, 2015
М. : Политическая энциклопедия, 2017
В 1936 году был издан первый том «Истории гражданской войны в СССР», посвященный революции 1917 года. Он произвел переворот в историографии вопроса, будучи официальной политической версией событий, произошедших с февраля по октябрь 1917 года. Сборник документов раскрывает процесс подготовки этой книги с 1929 по 1936 год, а также ее последующую судьбу. Текст издания 1936 года ...
Added: April 14, 2020
Akopov S., Управленческое консультирование 2015 № 2 С. 107-114
The objective of this article is the review and critique of the analysis of global citizenship through the lens of political philosophy of communitarianism, neo-Marxist world-system analysis, liberal nationalism and traditionalism. ...
Added: March 11, 2016
Zhukova O., Вопросы философии 2016 № 12 С. 111-116
“History of the Russian State” is a unique phenomenon of Russian culture. Karamzin was the first who had the distinction of returning the flow of Russian history back, as it were, into the river-bed of national life. Through addressing the memory of the people, Karamzin has recreated Russian history within an aesthetic framework of the late Enlightenment and ...
Added: December 14, 2016
P. : l’Institut de la gestion publique et du développement économique, 2018
Après la publication consacrée à la mobilisation financière pendant la Grande guerre (2015) et celle centrée sur le désordre des finances publiques en temps de guerre (2016), ce troisième volume entend se pencher sur l’appel à la fiscalité. L'ouvrage poursuit l'étude comparée du financement de la Grande Guerre par les différents pays belligérants. Le patriotisme ...
Added: November 2, 2017
Gorizontov L., Славянский альманах 2016 № 1-2 С. 69-81
After the beginning of the First World War the Polish presence in Russia increased substantially: numerous refugees and prisoners of war joined the earlier established Polonia. The complex process of national self-determination of the Poles was refl ected in the memoirs of Roman Dyboski (1883-1945) – a literary scholar, professor of Jagiellonian University, offi cer ...
Added: April 22, 2017
М. : Новое литературное обозрение, 2014
Хотя Первая мировая война стала для России историческим водоразделом, в историографии и в общественнном сознании она ассоциируется в основном с событиями на Западном фронте. Этому способствовало разделение российской истории начала ХХ века на дореволюционный и советский периоды. Цель сборника - включить в общеевропейский контекст мханизмы усвоения, истолкования и переработки российского опыта Первой мировой войны и ...
Added: May 5, 2014
Лаптев А. К., Известия Смоленского государственного университета 2016 № 3 (35) С. 295-300
This article discusses the activities of Smolensk Provincial Gendarmerie and the provincial police during the World War I, when the gendarmerie and the police faced new challenges dictated by the realities of war. Analysis of the activities of the security forces allowed the author to determine the specifics of law enforcement on the territory of ...
Added: October 31, 2020
М. : Издательство Московского университета, 2014
The First World War became a watershed in the European and world history. 100 years after the outbreak of the Great War historians continue to debate a role of this milestone event in the development of European civilization. The authors of the monograph try to make their own contribution to this discussion.
Designated for historians and ...
Added: October 23, 2014
Yakovenko V., В кн. : Конструируя "советское"? Политическое сознание, повседневные практики, новые идентичности: материалы одиннадцатой международной конференции студентов и аспирантов. : СПб. : Издательство Европейского университета в Санкт-Петербурге, 2017. С. 193-199.
В статье проанализированы различные аспекты и проблемы городского управления и самоуправления на территории Вооруженных сил Юга России в 1919 году. ...
Added: April 12, 2019
Yakovenko V., / Basic Research Programme. Series HUM "Humanities". 2019. No. 176.
Added: May 27, 2019
Malinkin A. N., Философия и культура 2016 Т. 101 № 5 С. 753-762
Subject of research – the legal and moral consciousness of the Russian falerists who collects signs the state awards of the RSFSR, USSR and Russia, as well as prevailing public opinion about them. In force of the relevant criminal law the group's activities illegal Russian falerists and their historical investigations are therefore anonymous and confidential. ...
Added: February 20, 2017