Organizational Ambidexterity and Performance: Assessment Approaches and Empirical Evidence

Journal of the Knowledge Economy. 2020. No. 11. P. 676–691.

Dranev Y., Izosimova A., Meissner D.

Three approaches are developed for assessment of different types of organizational ambidexterity proposed in the relevant literature. The new model for measurement of organizational ambidexterity using data envelopment analysis (DEA) is introduced. The DEA score based on innovation activity inputs and two different performance outputs acts as a proxy for organizational ambidexterity. Sustainability goals and product ambidexterity are also analyzed as the key characteristics of ambidextrous behavior. The introduced three approaches are tested for their aptness to complement
each other as well as to support a strategic decision-making. Empirical examples from energy and pharma sectors associate organizational ambidexterity with firms’ performance. We measured the organizational ambidexterity of energy and pharma companies by (1) pursuing long-term versus short-term organizational performance measured
as a DEA two-output efficiency score; (2) the share of disruptive products in a company’s activities assessed through the proportion of R&D expenditure or sales; and (3) sustainability versus financial performance of the company, where the Green ranking and participation in innovative financing programs were used as proxies for sustainable development. Positive relation between performance and organizational ambidexterity for energy sector are discovered. At the same time, orientation towards sustainability disrupts performance of pharmaceutical companies. Results of the OA impact on performance are highly industry-sensitive and depend on the methods used in empirical assessment. Our findings suggest that the scarcity of data sources make all three approaches complementary and mainly functional for strategic decision-making.

Keywords: инновации, устойчивое развитие, инновационные стратегии, organizational performance, innovation strategy, sustainable development, Organizational ambidexterity, Data envelopment analysis (DEA)

Publication based on the results of: Подготовка прогнозно-аналитических материалов с использованием анализа "больших" данных в целях разработки прогноза по приоритету "20в" "Переход к персонализированной медицине, высокотехнологичному здравоохранению и технологиям здоровьесбережения, в том числе за счет рационального применения лекарственных препаратов (прежде всего антибактериальных) Стратегии научно-технологического развития Российской Федерации" (2017)