Тропер М., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 184-195
In this article Michel Troper discusses the extent to which constitutional judges are free in their activity of interpreting laws. Three different approaches to legal interpretation yield different results in explaining liberty of interpretation. Interpretation as cognition is rejected by the author who reveals a vicious circle in the reasoning of partisans of this theory. ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Тропер М., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 180-183
In this article M. Troper draws attention of the Russian-speaking readers to actuality of the problems raised in the debates around his neorealist theory of legal interpretation. He also stresses importance of this translation for development of the theoretical jurisprudence in Russia. ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Пферсманн О., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 218-272
The author criticizes the neorealist conception of legal interpretation defended by Michel Troper. It is stressed that the neorealist approach to interpretation does not allow proving its own theses from a scientific standpoint. Subjectivist and voluntarist understanding of interpretation leads neorealism to a sociological conception of law. This understanding does not catch the most essential ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Antonov M., В кн. : Проблемы методологии и философии права. : Самара : Самарская гуманитарная академия, 2015. С. 116-131.
This paper deals with the neorealist theory of interpretation elaborated by the French legal scholar, Michel Troper. The basic theses and problems of this theory, as well as the debates about it are elucidated in the present article. In author’s opinion, an analysis of the neorealist theory allows unveiling many interesting aspects that are important ...
Added: October 5, 2015
Тропер М., Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 2012 № 4 С. 91-103
In this article the author examines the problems connected with definition of nature of constitutional interpretation. On the base of the cases from the judicial practice, Michel Troper shows that specificity of constitutional interpretation does not reside in particular character of constitution which is the object of interpretation. According to this French theorist who is ...
Added: May 8, 2013
Тропер М., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 196-204
In this article M. Troper sets out the key ideas of his realist theory of legal interpretation through juxtaposition of these ideas to the conception of interpretation developed by the Austrian philosopher Hans Kelsen. Troper insists that logical coherence of the Kelsenian understanding of a legal norm as of a meaning inevitably leads to the ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Тропер М., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 273-291
The author of this paper responds to the critique of the realist theory of interpretation made by O. Pfersmann. M. Troper insists that critique of his theory is based on the incorrect philosophical generalizations. The realist theory considers that it is impossible to find an objective meaning of legal texts also through judicial process. Thus, ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Markin M., Экономическая социология 2015 Т. 16 № 3 С. 143-162
Economic sociology of law is an approach within the new economic sociology that emerged at the end of the twentieth century. Since there are well-known traditions of studying law both in sociology and in economic theory, economic sociology of law needed to justify its development as a distinct subfield. First, the sociology of law is ...
Added: July 6, 2015
Antonov M., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 321-345
This article introduces publication of a series of works on interpretation of law by the French legal scholar Michel Troper, as well the materials of debates between Troper and Otto Pfersmann on the issues connected with legal interpretation. The author characterizes Troper’s conception of interpretation, summarizes the key elements of the critic made by Pfersmann, ...
Added: February 13, 2013
Lesiv B., В кн. : Философия права. Очерки. : М. : Проспект, 2022. С. 138-160.
Эта глава книги "Философия права. Очерки" посвящена историко-правовому бэкграунту и основным постулатам реалистического взгляда на онтологию права, которую развивал судья Верховного Суда США О. У. Холмс в конце XIX - начале XX вв. Дается авторская интерепретация основных положений правовой доктрины О. Холмса в контексте историко-правовых закономерностей развития англо-американского общего права. ...
Added: November 18, 2023
Тимошина Е. В., Васильева Н. С., Кондуров В. Е. et al., Вестник Российского фонда фундаментальных исследований. Гуманитарные и общественные науки 2021 № 3 С. 93-104
Notions of validity and efficacy of law have long been in the spotlight of jurisprudence, but the discussion on the respective issues is of a circular nature. We propose to systematize the existing approaches to legal validity on the basis of two criteria: 1) foundation of validity and 2) relation between validity and efficacy. This ...
Added: November 9, 2021
Antonov M., В кн. : Проблемы методологии и философии права. : Самара : Самарская гуманитарная академия, 2016. С. 56-67.
В данной работе рассматривается вопрос о роли учения об обязывающей силе права в социолого-правовой концепции Н.С. Тимашева. Автор анализирует критику этого аспекта учения Тимашева со стороны К. Оливекроны и приходит к выводу о том, что здесь позиция Тимашева расходится с методологической позицией его учителя Л.И. Петражицкого. По мнению автора, вопрос об обязывающей силе права имеет ...
Added: February 4, 2017
Antonov M., В кн. : Современные подходы к пониманию права и их влияние на развитие отраслевой юридической науки, законодательства и правоприменительной практики. : Мн. : Издательство Академии МВД РБ, 2017. С. 7-15.
СТАНОВЛЕНИЕ ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОГО АНАЛИЗА ПРАВА
Нередко правовые нормы и институты, разработанные в одних юрисдикциях и правопорядках, оказываются значимыми и, возможно, даже более эффективными для других юрисдикций и правопорядков, чему свидетельством многочисленные случаи трансплантации, изучаемые в сравнительном правоведении. Несколько более сложная ситуация складывается с методологическими идеями и научными концепциями, которые возникают и получают смысл в рамках одних правовых ...
Added: June 23, 2017
Medushevsky A. N., , in : Russian Legal Realism. : Berlin : Springer, 2018. Ch. 3.
The overarching goal of this chapter is to examine the nature of the Russian psychological school of law from the perspective of the international realist movement. This will allow us to define its most common characteristics, its original ideas and general influence on the development of legal philosophy. Discussing the crisis of legal thought at ...
Added: March 6, 2018
Kashanin A., Tretyakov S. V., В кн. : Правовые акты: оценка последствий. : М. : Юриспруденция, 2011. Гл. 1. С. 4-55.
Глава посвящена анализу теоретических подходов у оценке эффективности нормативных правовых актов ...
Added: November 22, 2012
Lesiv B., М. : Проспект, 2023
Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. (1841-1935) was an outstanding American jurist, who served as an Associate Justice of the US Supreme Court from 1902 to 1932. The history of legal doctrines regards him as a founder-father of a sociological and realistic schools. His ideas and observations developed by followers of legal realism and sociological jurisprudence founded ...
Added: November 17, 2023
Antonov M., Posner R. A., Gadzhiev G. A., Review of Central and East European Law 2017 Vol. 42 P. 73-94
The paper analyzes the key ideas of Justice Gadzhiev and Judge Posner on legal methodology and tasks in legal education. These ideas are considered in the context of two recent books by these authors. Both books appeared in 2016 and both question certain principal dimensions of pragmatism in the law, to which both Gadzhiev and ...
Added: June 29, 2017
Lesiv B., Юридическое образование и наука 2021 № 6 С. 23-28
In the Russian legal discourse, many appeals are made to the figure of O.W. Holmes, Jr. as a luminary of the realistic legal understanding. Most of the references relate to the maxims contained in his fundamental works, namely “The Common Law” and “The Path of the Law”. However, the ideological content of these works’ titles ...
Added: November 19, 2023
Budapest : Central European University Pre, 2006
The book containts articles written by European scholars about the place of socio-economic rights in the modern democracies. The introduction is written by Wiktor Osiatynski, who analyses the confusing concepts of socio-economic rights. ...
Added: August 30, 2012
Antonov M., Review of Central and East European Law 2018 Vol. 43 P. 87-98
The present paper is a review of Everyday Law in Russia by Professor Hendley. The review underscores that Professor Hendley pays attention not only to the texts of positive law: she also examines how the law works in these countries, how it is utilized by legal actors and how it matters to them. Professor Hendley’s analysis includes a ...
Added: January 28, 2018
Lesiv B., Правосудие 2023 Т. 5 № 2 С. 43-66
Introduction. Legal theorists remain engaged in a discussion on the phenomenon of judicial law-making and its manifestations in modern legal systems. This article through the writings of the famous judge O. W. Holmes, Jr., traces the prerequisites for the conclusion that law is what the court will decide, and the reveals actual content of the ...
Added: November 18, 2023
Didikin A., Афонасин Е. В., Новосибирск : НГУ, 2006
В учебном пособии излагаются темы учебного курса по философии права и хрестоматия, включающая в себя фрагменты текстов известных философов права в авторском переводе ...
Added: February 17, 2018
Antonov M., , in : Russian Legal Realism. : Berlin : Springer, 2018. Ch. 7. P. 127-138.
This paper considers the ways in which Leon Petrażycki and Eugen Ehrlich employed the psychological notion of emotions in defining the law. Both scholars defined the law by referring to special kinds of emotions: bilateral emotions in Petrażycki’s conception and repulsive emotions of experiencing the wrong behavior of other people, according to Ehrlich’s legal sociology. ...
Added: October 26, 2018
Теоретико-исторические оговорки, необходимые для адекватного восприятия правовой идеологии О. Холмса
Lesiv B., История государства и права 2021 № 5 С. 17-27
In Russian legal discourse there are frequent attempts to apply the postulates of a realistic legal understanding, formed by US Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, to continental legal realities. The findings of the American lawyer in relation to the jurisprudence of the United States are transferring to the Russian legal institutions without regard neither ...
Added: November 18, 2023