Отказ в возврате доли участия в корпорации в реалиях финансово-правового прессинга иностранных государств. Часть вторая: Оценки категории "справедливость" в тексте нормы п. 3 ст. 65.2 ГК РФ

Вестник Саратовской государственной юридической академии. 2022. № 4 (147). С. 87–93.

Malbin D., Колодуб Г. В.

The article is a continuation of the public discussion raised by the authors on the pages of the journal. The content of the second article is related to the justified criticism of the provisions of the norm of clause 3 of Article 65.2 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, which forms the provision on the refusal to return the share of participation in the corporation. The practical inapplicability of such a condition for refusal to return a share is seen as a possibility of negative social and other publicly significant consequences; the decision of the legislator to create competition for claims for compensation and damages is criticized; the fallacy of introducing the institute of fair compensation for the loss of a share in a corporation into Russian corporate law is proved. An effective construction of a claim for the return of a share in a corporation should be associated with the need to implement the institution of protection of a bona fide acquirer in corporate law.

Keywords: справедливость, корпорация, corporation, justice, right to participate, восстановление корпоративного контроля, restoration of corporate control, право участия, mechanism for exercising civil rights, guaranteeing civil law, share in the authorized capital, механизм осуществления прав, гарантированность гражданских прав, доля в уставном капитале