?
Crossing the Line: New Intuitions Behind Frankfurt-Type Cases
Axiomathes. 2017. Vol. 27. No. 4. P. 393–402.
Mishura A.
Frankfurt-type cases with covered manipulation received a great attention in the
debates about freedom of will and moral responsibility. They pretend to give the
refutation of the Principle of Alternative Possibilities (PAP) and to show that we can
intuitively blame or praise an agent who was not able to do otherwise. In this paper, I
will try to make explicit some basic intuitions underlying the agent's responsibility in
Frankfurt-type cases, which were surprisingly ignored in the contemporary debates.
The key intuition is that the responsibility of the agent in Frankfurt-type cases is always
grounded at the point of overcoming the uncertainty preceding action. This overcoming
is crucially important for agent's responsibility and immune to any manipulation of
counterfactual intervener.
Keywords: responsibilityfreedomсвобода волиcompatibilismкомпатибилизмморальная ответственностьalternative possibilitiesFrankfurt cases
Publication based on the results of:
Strizhkova D., / Институт русской литературы (Пушкинский Дом) РАН. Серия B001 "Репозиторий открытых данных по русской литературе и фольклору". 2026.
В базе данных представлена роспись русскоязычных литературных произведений и отрывков, напечатанных в учебниках по словесности, хрестоматиях, книгах для чтения, сборниках стихотворений и рассказов, выходивших во Франции, Германии, Латвии, Эстонии, Болгарии, Сербии в период первой волны русской эмиграции с 1918 по 1939 гг. Датасет представляет интерес для исследователей школьного литературного канона, эмиграции и детского чтения ...
Added: April 22, 2026
Жигунов А. Ю., / Basic Research Programme. Серия HUM "Humanities". 2026. № 1.
The article attempts to describe the features of the educational potential of Russian animation programmes in aspect of the representation of traditional spiritual and moral values. Based on media and semiotic analysis, the method of cultural and historical interpretation, animated Russian projects created from 2000 to the 2025, which were translated on television channels or streaming ...
Added: April 19, 2026
Poddiakov A., Троицкий вариант. Наука 2026 № 4 (448) С. 19–21
Научные дискуссии о том, есть ли свобода воли у человека, ведутся столетиями, в том числе в настоящее время профессионалами высокого уровня из разных областей. Обоснования отсутствия свободы воли, выдвигаемые частью нейроученых, сводятся к трем основным положениям.
1. Существование свободы воли можно опровергнуть возможностью прогнозирования якобы «свободных» действий. Но тот, чье поведение спрогнозировали извне, не может считаться ...
Added: March 1, 2026
Tulchinskii G. L., Образовательная политика 2025 Т. 22 № 3 С. 10–18
The article examines the content of the philosophy of the act presented by a prominent Russian philosopher, literary critic, and cultural theorist Mikhail Bakhtin. The author provides the reader with a particularly detailed introduction to the Russian philosopher’s main concept. According to the author, Mikhail Bakhtin’s legacy can be seen as a continuation of the theory of ...
Added: January 29, 2026
М.: Ад Маргинем Пресс, 2025.
In his essay "On Photography," the prominent German media theorist Vilém Flusser (1920-1991) asks whether human freedom is possible in the information society, in a world dominated by cameras, where our thoughts, feelings, desires, and actions are robotized. The photographer's intentions are inscribed within the strictly limited corridor of the camera's program—a black box simulating ...
Added: January 22, 2026
Карпова Е. А., Философия. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2025 Vol. 9 No. 4 P. 152–169
As artificial intelligence systems increasingly mediate decisions in domains such as healthcare, law, finance, and national security, traditional notions of moral agency and respon- sibility are being subjected to unprecedented scrutiny. Decisions once regarded as the sole prerogative of human judgment are now frequently delegated to or shaped by algorithmic processes, raising fundamental questions about ...
Added: January 1, 2026
Гуляева О. Н., Lex Russica (Русский закон) 2025 Т. 78 № 3 (220) С. 31–40
Идеи равенства и свободы договора в гражданских правоотношениях являются гармоничными и конструктивными исключительно в условиях их ограничения. Одним из факторов, требующих установления границ, – наличие слабой стороны в правоотношениях, в частности, потребителя. Статья посвящена изучению манипулирования в отношении непрофессиональных участников гражданского оборота. Автор предпринимает попытку правовой оценки новых методов воздействия на волю потребителей, направленных на ...
Added: November 24, 2025
Голубов М. Д., Человек 2026 Т. 37 № 1 С. 133–154
This article offers an interpretation of certain elements of Lacan’s teaching as an original solution to the problem of freedom inherited from Kojève, alongside the theory of the subject. Our interpretation expands the scope of research in several ways. Firstly, it enables us to deepen our study of Kojève’s influence and reconstruct the historical and ...
Added: November 22, 2025
Дмитриева О. В., Журнал российского права 2025 Т. 29 № 10 С. 97–113
The involvement of intangible assets (unification) in civil turnover contradicts the ideas
of intangible assets that have developed in Russian civil law and reflected in civil legislation as objects
that are inalienable from the subject, are not subject to monetary valuation, and therefore are not
Journal of Russian L 98 aw, 2025, vol. 29, no. 10
able to participate ...
Added: November 12, 2025
Рахманова Л. Я., Социология власти 2025 Т. 37 № 1 С. 82–116
The article examines how — due to certain infrastructural, bureaucratic,legislative, regional conditions, and contexts — territories, communities, biographical trajectories, and temporalities that do not obey rural social logic emerged in the Middle Ob region in the 2010s–2020s. The focus is on a layer of little-studied spaces — huts, fishing bases, farmsteads outside settlements. The temporal logic within which these ...
Added: November 11, 2025
Малахов В. С., Симон М. Е., Летняков Д. Э. et al., / SSRN. Серия Social Science Research Network "Social Science Research Network". 2020.
The notion of “political accommodation” applied to the theory and practice of managing cultural diversity could enrich the Russian academic dictionary. Liberal democratic states invented specific mechanisms for political accommodation of cultural differences. Thanks to these mechanisms, the part of the population of a democratic state that is not ready to dissolve into the ethnocultural ...
Added: September 26, 2025
Melville A. Y., Каберник В. В., Mironyuk M. et al., / МГИМО МИД России. 2024.
Данный аналитический доклад является одним из результатов исследований в рамках консорциума НИУ ВШЭ и МГИМО. В нем прежде всего раскрыты вопросы концептуализации национальной мощи и сопутствующих категорий и дается обзор прецедентов. Далее рассматриваются вопросы операционализации предлагаемых нами компонентов национальной мощи. В следующих разделах доклада предлагается анализ вопросов методологии, используемой в докладе. На этой основе предложен ...
Added: September 19, 2025
Leontiev D., Философские науки 2025 Т. 68 № 1 С. 79–91
The paper examines the issue of the humane in the human being in the context of the dialectic between ideals and reality. Reflecting on discussions about human essence leads to the conclusion of its inherent indeterminacy and the multiplicity of potential capabilities within each individual, which develop throughout life. The distinction between ideal and reality ...
Added: September 11, 2025
Mavrinsky I., Новое литературное обозрение 2025 № 3(193) С. 46–60
In the critique of modernity, common themes include the rejection of foundations, the demand for the decentering of the subject, and the questioning of binary oppositions between center and periphery, depth and surface. The explication of these commonplace assumptions problematizes the border both in its various definitions and in terms of its conceptualization. In this ...
Added: July 2, 2025
Shabanova M. A., Экономическая социология 2025 Т. 26 № 2 С. 14–52
This paper substantiates a theoretical concept and tests hypotheses concerning the relationship between ethical consumption as a new sphere of civil society (CS) and its traditional sphere (formal and informal structures beyond the consumption sphere). For the first time, the paper presents the data on Russians’ participation in a wide range of ethical consumption practices ...
Added: April 1, 2025
Faul B., Эпистемология и философия науки 2025 Т. 62 № 1 С. 83–98
In this paper, the author offers a phenomenological argumentthat we are libertarian agents: we can choose between alterna-tive possibilities and are the sources of our actions. The authordemonstrates that it is necessary to accept the evidence of expe-rience unless there are sufficient reasons against it becauseotherwise, it leads to global skepticism. Further, the author con-siders ...
Added: March 14, 2025
Antipkina I., Ivanov A., Guzhelya D., / Series WP BRP "Basic research program". 2024.
This study presents a methodology for developing a new questionnaire format called explicit continuum scenario scales, in the example of a client focus questionnaire. Elements of the Rasch Guttman scenario scale methodology were used in its development. In three consequent studies, different aspects of the scale functioning were investigated. In Study 1, on the sample ...
Added: February 21, 2025
Grebnev L., Высшее образование в России 2024 Т. 33 № 12 С. 155–168
Using examples of the introduction of the Unified State Exam and participation
in the Bologna process, the article analyzes changes in the regulatory framework for budgetary
financing of education as a reaction to external circumstances. The role of the family and
educational institutions in fostering a sense of responsibility for decisions and the results of their
implementation is also ...
Added: January 22, 2025
Глебова С. В., Перов В. Ю., Человек 2023 Т. 34 № 3 С. 41–59
The problem of moral responsibility occupies a key place in modern ethical studies. Based on the discussions formed in the academic field, the article considers the features of two main approaches to the definition of moral responsibility and the conditions for its onset: descriptive and normative. It is shown that despite the fact that the ...
Added: December 11, 2024
Aitzhanov S., / NRU HSE. Series WP BRP "Linguistics". 2024. No. 116.
This study focuses on examining the role of language as an attribute in the construction of ethnicity within the Korean community in Kazakhstan. The research examines how language functions as an attribute in the categorization and identification processes, and how it interacts with other ethnic attributes such as descent and appearance. Drawing on qualitative methods, ...
Added: December 10, 2024
Sofia Glebova, Перов В. Ю., Social Sciences (USA) 2023 Vol. 54 No. 003 P. 95–106
The problem of moral responsibility is central to modern ethical research. Based on debates in the academic field, this article examines two main approaches to defining moral responsibility and the conditions under which it arises: descriptive and normative. We show that even though the descriptive approach aspires to objectivity in imputing and ascribing moral responsibility, ...
Added: December 8, 2024
Rodkin P. E., Вестник культурологии 2024 № 3(110) С. 150–169
The representation of freedom as a symbol of an abstract idea and a real socio-political and cultural phenomenon is the most difficult task of art. A significant problem is the symbolic reproducibility of such an image in different historical eras. The article examines the technical and semantic reproducibility of the central image of the painting ...
Added: November 29, 2024
Микаелян А. Л., / NRU Higher School of Economics. Series WP BRP "Literary Studies". 2024. No. 28.
The article presents an attempt to examine Goethe's poem "Reineke Fox" in connection with the discussion between Goethe and Schiller about the nature of epic poetry and the principles of its renewal within the poetics of "Weimar Classicism". Goethe introduced into his interpretation of the medieval story of the Fox a number of innovations at various ...
Added: November 19, 2024
Leontiev D., Вопросы образования 2024 № 1 С. 142–161
The paper presents a systematic analysis of key explanatory concepts of different levels of abstraction, being used in the psychological and interdisciplinary concepts for the explanation of the phenomenon of self-sufficiency. The phenomenon of self-sufficiency is defined basing on the understanding of person as the instance which human being as an autonomous agent may oppose ...
Added: November 7, 2024