Personality Cults in Modern Politics: Cases from Russia and China
Lu X., Soboleva E.
The popularization of Area Studies in the USA during the Cold War was driven by international political considerations, in particular the need to produce knowledge about so-called enemy countries – communist states. As the political systems of the major representatives of the communist bloc - USSR, China, North Korea – developed the phenomenon of personality cults, it consequently became an important subject for Area Studies scholars, as well as its new concept. They approached this phenomenon through multidisciplinary culturally and historically contextualized studies instead of applying macro-historical theories based on the Western experience (Szanton, 2002: 5-11). The term “personality cult” became popular after Nikita Khrushchev’s “Secret speech” at the 20th Party Congress in 1956, when he used it to explain the consolidation of Stalin’s personal dictatorship, the ensuing abuses of power and the extraordinary adulation of Stalin (Rees, 2004:3). Since then the term has had a highly negative connotation and is associated with the notorious human rights abuses of Stalinism, as well as the regimes of Mao Zedong, Adolf Hitler and the Kim family in North Korea. The term, personality cult, when applied to modern politics, usually refers to the practice of non-democratic regimes to promote an idealized image of a leader with the aid of modern mass media in order to generate personal worship in a society. Although the practice of personality cults in modern states arguably started with the Russian leader Stalin’s decision to place the corpse of Vladimir Lenin on public display after Lenin’s death in 1924 (Rutland, 2011:365), the spirit of the phenomenon is extremely ancient. “The deification of dead emperors and then of living emperors was used to legitimize personal power in ancient Greece and Rome, especially with the dynasty of Augustus” (Rees, 2004:7). However, technology improvements utilized in mass media and police monitoring activities have made modern states more capable of creating and sustaining a personality cult. The popularity of the personality cult as a research topic in Sino, Soviet and Korean studies can be explained by a specific approach undertaken by foreign scholars studying the policies and politics of these states (these studies are also known as Kremlinology). The lack of reliable information and the highly opaque decision making structures in these communist states have made it necessary for Kremlinologists to read between the lines and employ such empirical data as the physical position of members of the inner circles during parades, the wording in newspaper articles, the presence or absence of slogans and phrases in documents, etc. That also explains why they focused on the visible actors – leaders – and therewith shaped the research of personality cults. “In identifying cleavages and controversies within the Soviet leadership, Kremlinologists have tended to emphasize personal alignments, overstate personal power struggles and downgrade policy issues to mere instruments in the fight for supremacy” (Jönsson, 1977:132). With the end of the Cold War a new understanding of the personality cult has begun to develop. It has been argued that this concept should be put in a broader context of person-centered modern symbolic politics, opening up vistas for comparisons with Western democracies. According to E.A. Rees (2004:7) “embryonic cults exist even in relatively open, democratic political systems”. These are not personality cults in the full form, but they resemble them in some respects. So the ghost of the personality cult is not peculiar to non-democratic states, but the political and social conditions in non-democratic states serve as a more comfortable hotbed in which it can grow. The first section of the working paper will provide a theoretic framework for the analysis of personality cults: from Weber’s theory of charismatic authority to theoretical developments specifically related to personality cults. The following sections will present case studies of subjects of the most famous personality cults: Joseph Stalin and Mao Zedong, and also look into more recent developments, such as the idolization of Vladimir Putin in modern Russia
, Новая и новейшая история 2022
In XXI century China more actively uses the historical memory as a tool of the international relations. The aim of contemporary Chinese historical narratives is to consolidate nation. The core of these narratives is triumphalism, which is connected with the victory in the World War 2 and achievements of the Chinese empire. Narratives about traumatic ...
Added: May 25, 2022
, Laxenburg: IIASA, 2019
On 15 March 2019, the first “Connecting Eurasia Dialogue: From the Atlantic to the Pacific” was held in Brussels, at Europe’s political heart. The event was organized by the Roscongress Foundation and the Conoscere Eurasia Association with the support of the Association of European Businesses and the Belgian-Luxembourg Chamber of Commerce. Amid the current political ...
Added: May 10, 2019
, , et al., М.: НИУ ВШЭ, 2018
In connection with a number of significant events that took place in May 2018, the HSE research group offers readers a special edition of the Eurasian Panorama devoted to the analysis of the four directions of Eurasian integration. On May 14, 2018, at the summit of the Supreme Eurasian Economic Council, Moldova became the first country to be ...
Added: April 24, 2018
, Свободная мысль 2015 № 4 С. 208-216
В рецензии осущеслён обзор элетронной публикации дневников А. Дмитриева - рабочего авиамоторного завода в г. Молотов. [О. Л. Лейбович, А. С. Кимерлинг и др. Дневник рабочего (III.1946 – XII.1955). Документальная публикация. Пермь: ПермГАНИ, 2014 (Электронный ресурс)] Особенности развития политических процессов в современной России способствуют поиску исторических и иных параллелей с периодом правления И. Сталина. Российская власть ...
Added: October 4, 2015
, , Мировая экономика и международные отношения 2021 Т. 65 № 2 С. 5-15
Territorial dispute in the South China Sea (SCS) which involves China and several ASEAN member-states has recently become one of the major threats to international security in Southeast Asia leading to continuous political tensions in the region. It may result not only in a split within ASEAN but also in drawing the non-regional powers into ...
Added: February 3, 2021
, , Russian Politics and Law 2016 Vol. 54 No. 5-6 P. 494-515
One of the main issues facing the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) is its enlargement. Traditionally, this issue has been viewed in terms of practical policy. The longer this dispute over enlargement drags on, however, the greater the depth it acquires. The enlargement debate reflects the unique political culture of the SCO. Another issue well-known from ...
Added: August 14, 2017
The Gathering Pacific Storm: Emerging US-China Strategic Competition in Defense Technological and Industrial Development
, , Cambria, 2018
The United States has enjoyed overwhelming military technological superiority in the post-Cold War era, but China has begun to chip away at this dominance. As distrust and strategic rivalry becomes more prominent in US-China relations, this is helping to turn what had previously been parallel but separate military research and development efforts by both countries ...
Added: October 16, 2018
, , Китай в мировой и региональной политике. История и современность 2017 Т. 22 № 22 С. 187-203
The article deals with the settlement of the crisis of 2010-2016. in relations between China and Norway, which arose after the award of the Nobel Peace Prize to the Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo. Mutual trust was restored, above all, through closed diplomatic negotiations. At the same time, Norway was subjected to serious pressure from China, ...
Added: November 1, 2018
, Проблемы Дальнего Востока 2016 № 2 С. 50-58
Статья развивает тему, поднятую в прошлогодней публикации «Девальвация юаня: причины и последствия» (ПДВ. 2015. № 5). В ней рассматриваются события, связанные с дальнейшими шагами Китая по реформированию механизма установления валютного курса и с девальвацией юаня в конце 2015 - начале 2016 гг. ...
Added: October 6, 2020
Ключевые проблемы модернизации России и Китая: направления сравнительных исследований. Вводное выступление за «круглым столом» - «Модернизация в России и Китае в сравнительной перспективе»
, Российская история 2012 № 3 С. 45-48
Данная публикация материалов российско-китайского Круглого стола посвящена актуальным проблемам модернизации в двух странах в истории и современности. Показаны возможности сопоставления «военного коммунизма» и «большого скачка», технологий построения индустриального общества и становления политических режимов. ...
Added: December 1, 2012
21st Conference of the European Association for Chinese Studies. St. Petersburg, August 23-28, 2016: Book of Abstracts
St. Petersburg: NP-PRINT, 2016
This book contains the abstracts of the presentations delivered by the participants of the 21st Conference of the European Association for Chinese Studies (Saint-Petersburg, August 23-28, 2016). The materials deal with a large scope of the issues related to the studies of contemporary and traditional China. ...
Added: August 26, 2016
, , , М.: Просвещение, 2018
Учебное пособие 9 класса предназначено для обучающихся общеобразовательных организаций, начинающих изучать китайский язык в качестве второго иностранного языка с 5 класса (пятый год обучения). Подготовлено в соответствии с требованиями Федерального государственного образовательного стандарта основного общего образования. Сбалансированная структура учебника, большой объём страноведческих знаний, аутентичность текстов, педагогически выверенные материалы для аудирования и тренировочных упражнений, привлекательный дизайн, ...
Added: June 20, 2018
, , Фонд изучения исторической перспективы, 2018
Within a brief historical period, BRICS as an inter-State association has become an influential player in the world economy and politics. BRICS is a primarily political entity, and in that regard, the BRICS grouping correlates with the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO). However, not all the expectations placed on the SCO by the founding countries at ...
Added: October 29, 2018
, , China Report 2020 Vol. 56 No. 3 P. 415-418
It would not be an exaggeration to remark that China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has created a dazzling discourse in academia since its inception in 2013 and that the number of papers, books and monographs written on this gigantic project have shown the good, bad and ugly side of a BRI that encompasses around ...
Added: September 17, 2020
, Полития: Анализ. Хроника. Прогноз 2019 № 3 С. 33-54
The article is devoted to the problem of political authority that is viewed as a fact of a social reality. The author regards authority as a sociopolitical institution rooted in the biological nature of a human being and evolving throughout the history. The article suggests a framework for a holistic theory of political authority and ...
Added: November 4, 2019
Возможности развития российско-китайской промышленной кооперации на основе опыта военно-технического сотрудничества двух стран
, Благовещенск: Благовещенский государственный педагогический университет, 2016
The article focuses on the opportunities for Russian-Chinese industrial cooperation development on the basis of military-technical cooperation between the two countries. ...
Added: January 27, 2017
, Сравнительная политика 2020 Т. 11 № 2 С. 76-88
The article deals with the problems of joint actions of Russia, India, and China to mitigate the terrorist threat from Islamist terrorists in the Central part of Eurasia. The author comes to the conclusion that, from an objective point of view, the three giants have completely uniform approaches to terrorism, separatism, and extremism. Moreover, along ...
Added: September 20, 2020
, , Восточная аналитика 2014 № 4 С. 36-41
Китайским властям надо быть готовым к некоторому риску социально-политической дестабилизации и постараться предпринять некоторые превентивные меры, которые могли бы данный риск смягчить (возможно, включая и поощрение деятельности брачных агентств, помогающих китайским мужчинам найти брачных партнеров заграницей). Вместе с тем, очевидно, что для долгосрочного фундаментального решения данной серьезной проблемы китайскому руководству необходимо как можно скорее отказываться ...
Added: October 19, 2014
, Southeast Asia: Actual Problems of Development 2022
The paper examines the dynamics in relations between the People’s Republic of China (PRC) and the South Pacific small island states collectively referred to as Pacific island countries (PICs). The specificity of current China’s policy is revealed, the reasons for concern from the PIC perspective are outlined, the aftereffects of the on-going political and security ...
Added: May 19, 2022
, International Journal of Business and Social Science 2012 Vol. 3 No. 8 P. 282-285
This paper attempts to ascertain the role of public diplomacy in the East Asian region and focuses on the civilization potentials of Russia and China in the region. Dialogue of civilizations, based not on conflict of cultures, values, but on movement to mutual understanding, collaboration and even to the process of harmonization of civilization, is ...
Added: September 20, 2012
, Сравнительная политика 2021 Т. 12 № 3 С. 63-84
The article analyzes the nature of the political system of modern China in the context of the typology of communist political regimes. The author argues that the typologies of communist regimes proposed so far are of little use, since the differences between the regimes were not considered deeply enough, while the ideology factor was not actually used ...
Added: August 27, 2021
, Проблемы Дальнего Востока 2015 № 1 С. 154-167
The article analyzes the activities of organizational structures of the Russian Federation in the implementation of the strategy of promotion of Russian language in China in the beginning of the XXI century. The author emphasizes that, having entered the new century, the Russian leadership has included the popularization of the Russian language in the list ...
Added: March 27, 2015
, , Китай в мировой и региональной политике. История и современность 2020 Т. 25 № 25 С. 137-153
The article is devoted to the development of China's relations with the UK and the EU in the process and as a result of Brexit. Nowadays the European direction in the foreign policy is one of the priorities for Beijing. In particular, since 2014 there has been an unprecedented upsurge in the foreign policy activity ...
Added: October 15, 2020
Помощь Китая вьетнамскому народу во время войны сопротивления против французских колонизаторов (1946-1954)
, , Проблемы Дальнего Востока 2012 № 1 С. 146-155
The article examines the main areas of assistance provided by China to Vietnam during the Resistance war against French colonialists (1946-1954). ...
Added: August 24, 2012