?
Проблема действительности по Кельзену
С. 344-237.
Булыгин Е. В.
Translator: Antonov M.
In the work are summarized the basic tenets of the theory of validity of legal norms; the ideas of Kelsen about legal validity are critically analyzed.
In book
Альчуррон К. Э., Булыгин Е. В. СПб. : Издательский дом СПбГУ, 2013
Васильева Н. С., Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Юридические науки 2017 Т. 21 № 3 С. 396-414
The article analyzes the main approaches to the problem of the validity of law. As a result a number of aspects of the phenomenon designated as “the validity of law” are distinguished: normative significance, social and (or) psychological efficiency, objective givenness, a binding force. To fill the gap in the theoretical constructions the author proposes ...
Added: October 27, 2019
Antonov M., Труды Института государства и права Российской академии наук 2013 № 4 С. 172-195
The author of this paper aims at summing up the key elements of legal doctrine developed by the Austrian legal thinker Hans Kelsen. Kelsen’s theory is multifaceted and it admits not only formally juridical but also sociological, philosophical, cultural, political understandings of law. Although, this thinker draws an exaggerated distinction between different scientific disciplines – ...
Added: November 11, 2013
Васильева Н. С., Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 2018 № 1 (336) С. 84-177
Alf Ross is one of the most prominent representatives of Scandinavian legal realism and one of the main participants of the discussion on legal validity. This article explores the main points of his realistic legal concept. Ross uses a unique mixture of the main tenets of logical positivism and the Uppsala school of philosophy to ...
Added: October 25, 2019
Antonov M., В кн. : Как возможна логика в праве?. : СПб. : Алетейя, 2021. С. 71-117.
The present paper examines how Eugenio Bulygin interprets a number of key problems of legal theory of Hans Kelsen. Among such problems are such as normativity of law, nature of legal norms, the distinction between norms and normative propositions, normative consequences of court decisions and their logical foundation, description of law-application in terms of logic, ...
Added: July 11, 2021
Antonov M., Право. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2013 № 1 С. 3-15
This article deals with the general characterization of the legal conception elaborated by the prominent jurist of the 20th century — Hans Kelsen (1881-1973). The author examines the basic biographic facts about intellectual formation of this Austrian legal thinker. The author particularly underlines the relationship between Kelsen’s ideas about law, and his practical activity as ...
Added: May 16, 2013
Antonov M., В кн. : Правопорядок: элементы общей теории. : М. : Издательство Проспект, 2020. С. 34-44.
One of the first stages of the knowledge of law in the history of ideas was the realization that the world, both physical and social, is ordered in a certain way and that the way in which this ordering occurs is not accidental. Whether the ordering comes from the will of gods or rulers, whether it ...
Added: December 18, 2020
Иештедт М., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 531-553
This article is the foreword to «Pure Theory of Law» by Hans Kelsen reedited in 2008. The author of this article, M. Jestaedt, mentions the most common mistakes and misunderstandings suffered by the legal theory of Kelsen. Jestaedt also stresses ambiguity in reception of Kelsenian ideas. He describes the context of creation and publication of ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Antonov M., В кн. : Мир человека: нормативное измерение – 3. Рациональность и легитимность. : Саратов : Саратовская государственная юридическая академия, 2013. С. 245-254.
В европейской правовой культуре принято рассматривать правовую норму как руководство к действию, способное определять поведенческий выбор субъектов права. Основная проблема заключается в том, может ли определять поведение субъекта не только норма, но также и практические (прагматические) соображения, которыми субъект руководствуется в своей повседневной деятельности. Эта проблематика выводит на вопросы применения экономического анализа в праве. Автор ...
Added: November 7, 2013
Antonov M., Право Украины 2013 Т. 4 № 2013 С. 189-211
In this article the author examines the question about a correlation between the pure theory of law and natural law doctrine. The author demonstrates that Kelsen’s was the idea of incompatibility of these two approaches to law. But one cannot consider the borderlines between different philosophical ideas about law as impenetrable. The critical remarks of ...
Added: February 4, 2014
Antonov M., В кн. : Этические и антропологические характеристики современного права в ситуации методологического плюрализма. : Мн. : Академия МВД Республики Беларусь, 2015. С. 93-100.
The author examines to which extent are possible in the scope of legal science and are effective different approaches to validity (binding force) of law in the context of classical and postclassical scientific paradigms. The difference of approaches reveals diverging methodological foundations for understanding law as unity and to comprehend such characteristics of law as ...
Added: April 8, 2015
Васильева Н. С., В кн. : Как возможна логика в праве?. : СПб. : Алетейя, 2021. С. 118-134.
Е. В. Булыгин конструирует наиболее современную и целостную теоретическую модель действительности и действенности права, выделяя нормативную действительность, понимаемую как обязывающая сила; фактическую действительность, рассматриваемую как действенность, эффективность; системную действительность, предназначенную для отграничения норм права от иных социальных норм и понимаемую как указание на принадлежность к определенной правовой системе. Свою модель Е. В. Булыгин основывает на развитии идей юридико-позитивистского, ...
Added: November 9, 2021
Antonov M., Российский журнал правовых исследований 2018 Т. 15 № 2 С. 118-124
The present paper has as its object the investigation into meanings of propositions about legitimacy of law and their possible conceptual interconnection with propositions about validity of law. The paper analyzes the genesis of the legitimacy discourse in law, the criteria of recognition in law and their significance for defeasibility of particular norms of law as ...
Added: November 11, 2018
Тимошина Е. В., Васильева Н. С., Кондуров В. Е. et al., Вестник Российского фонда фундаментальных исследований. Гуманитарные и общественные науки 2021 № 3 С. 93-104
Notions of validity and efficacy of law have long been in the spotlight of jurisprudence, but the discussion on the respective issues is of a circular nature. We propose to systematize the existing approaches to legal validity on the basis of two criteria: 1) foundation of validity and 2) relation between validity and efficacy. This ...
Added: November 9, 2021
Antonov M., Право. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2018 № 3 С. 24-49
The paper considers the legal and philosophical issue of the correlation between facticity and normativity in the aspect of regulation and protection of religious freedoms in the past contemporary Russian law. The paper suggests considering in this aspect the gap between the normative content and the meaning of the corresponding norms of Russian constitution and ...
Added: November 1, 2018
Antonov M., В кн. : ПРАВОВОЕ РЕГУЛИРОВАНИЕ: ПРОБЛЕМЫ ЭФФЕКТИВНОСТИ, ЛЕГИТИМНОСТИ, СПРАВЕДЛИВОСТИ. : Воронеж : НАУКА-ЮНИПРЕСС, 2016. С. 151-159.
This paper examines how works mechanism of legal regulation. The author considers main aspects of this issue from the vantage point of different approaches to law. The author concludes that legal positivism provides the most adequate methods for studying and explaining legal regulation. ...
Added: August 11, 2016
Полсон С., Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 2012 № 6 С. 158-175
A number of puzzles surround Kelsen’s doctrine of the normativity of the law. What, exactly, does it mean? Some writers in analytical jurisprudence have attributed a “justified” or “contentual” normativity thesis to Hans Kelsen. One representative of this view, Joseph Raz, goes so far as to claim that the “justified normativity thesis” defended by Kelsen ...
Added: May 8, 2013
Antonov M., В кн. : Нормативная теория Ганса Кельзена и развитие юриспруденции в Европе и США. : Иваново : Издательство ИвГУ, 2015. С. 134-153.
Чистое учение о праве Ганса Кельзена стало одним из наиболее значимых проектов философии права, особенно позитивистского направления. Среди позитивистски настроенных теоретиков права конкуренцию его концепции могли составить разве что только представители того движения англо-американской правовой мысли, которое было обозначено как «аналитическая философия права». Есть ли между этими двумя направлениями содержательная связь, либо их можно и ...
Added: June 15, 2015
Antonov M., Известия высших учебных заведений. Правоведение 2016 № 4 С. 6-15
This paper deals with the basic perspectives of the article by the famous Argentinian legal scholar Eugenio Bulygin that was devoted to the problem of efficiency of law. That article has been written in the very beginning of scholarly career of Professor Bulygin; it reflects the level of discussions on this problem in the world legal ...
Added: March 12, 2017
Antonov M., Право. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2021 Т. 3 С. 254-261
In his 2020 book "Hans Kelsen. A Biography of a Jurist," Professor Thomas Olechowski of the University of Vienna attempts to understand how life conditions may have shaped the theoretical ideas and personality of Hans Kelsen in general. This thousand-page monograph is a remarkable synthesis of the research work done in this area. On the ...
Added: January 5, 2022
Пферсманн О., Российский ежегодник теории права 2011 Т. 4 С. 218-272
The author criticizes the neorealist conception of legal interpretation defended by Michel Troper. It is stressed that the neorealist approach to interpretation does not allow proving its own theses from a scientific standpoint. Subjectivist and voluntarist understanding of interpretation leads neorealism to a sociological conception of law. This understanding does not catch the most essential ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Antonov M., В кн. : 210 лет МВД России: история и современность: Материалы всероссийской научно-практической конференции 21.09.2012. : СПб. : LAP LAMBERT Academic Publishing GmbH & Co. KG, 2013. С. 30-35.
In this paper the basic princips of the legal theory of Hans Kelsen are summarized. ...
Added: May 9, 2013
Иваново : Издательство ИвГУ, 2015
В сборник включены научные доклады, в которых было проанализировано научное наследие Ганса Кельзена. ...
Added: June 15, 2015
Antonov M., 2013 No. 1 P. 345-353
In this paper the author examines the key moment of the biography of the Austrian legal thinker, the founder of the Pure Theory of Law, Н. Kelsen. The biographical analysis is conducted in the context of formation of the legal ideas of Kelsen. A special accent is made on characteristic of the law-enforcement process which ...
Added: January 3, 2015
Antonov M., В кн. : Релятивизм в праве. : СПб. : Алетейя, 2021. Гл. 8. С. 144-168.
The separation thesis that there is no necessary connection between the operation of legal norms and values is one of the two main criteria (along with the social sources thesis) for distinguishing positivism from non-positivism. In debates about the merits and demerits of legal positivism, this thesis is often distorted, for example by claims that positivists ...
Added: October 10, 2021