• A
  • A
  • A
  • АБВ
  • АБВ
  • АБВ
  • A
  • A
  • A
  • A
  • A
Обычная версия сайта
  • RU
  • EN
  • HSE University
  • Publications
  • Articles
  • Are Mathematicians, Physicists and Biologists Irrational? Intransitivity Studies vs. the Transitivity Axiom
  • RU
  • EN
Расширенный поиск
Высшая школа экономики
Национальный исследовательский университет
Priority areas
  • business informatics
  • economics
  • engineering science
  • humanitarian
  • IT and mathematics
  • law
  • management
  • mathematics
  • sociology
  • state and public administration
by year
  • 2028
  • 2027
  • 2026
  • 2025
  • 2024
  • 2023
  • 2022
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016
  • 2015
  • 2014
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2008
  • 2007
  • 2006
  • 2005
  • 2004
  • 2003
  • 2002
  • 2001
  • 2000
  • 1999
  • 1998
  • 1997
  • 1996
  • 1995
  • 1994
  • 1993
  • 1992
  • 1991
  • 1990
  • 1989
  • 1988
  • 1987
  • 1986
  • 1985
  • 1984
  • 1983
  • 1982
  • 1981
  • 1980
  • 1979
  • 1978
  • 1977
  • 1976
  • 1975
  • 1974
  • 1973
  • 1972
  • 1971
  • 1970
  • 1969
  • 1968
  • 1967
  • 1966
  • 1965
  • 1964
  • 1963
  • 1958
  • More
Subject
News
September 15, 2026
Immunity to Chaos: How Personal Resources Help Us Cope with the Challenges of a Turbulent World
International conflicts, crises and digital overload—the modern world puts our minds to the test every day. Traditional psychology often focuses on the consequences: anxiety, depression, and psychosomatic disorders. But what if we looked at the problem differently—through the lens of the resources that prevent us from breaking down? Psychological immunity is precisely this set of resources. Alena Zolotareva and her group, Psychological Immunity as a Resource for Positive Functioning, are developing an integrative model of this phenomenon, adapting diagnostic tools and preparing for large-scale empirical research. Why do psychologists need to collaborate with medical professionals, and how could their research transform preventive care in clinics and corporations?
September 11, 2026
How to Assess Students Knowledge in the Age of AI
A researcher at HSE University has proposed a flowchart to help lecturers decide how to assess students who use artificial intelligence. It shows where the use of AI should be restricted and where it can be incorporated into the learning process. The article has been published in IT Professional.
September 9, 2026
‘Balkan Hospitality Opens Doors: Studying Dialects on the Verge of Extinction
You cannot study spoken dialects from books. Instead, you need to go to a village, seek out its elders, and earn the trust of local residents before you can record hours of spontaneous stories. This is how Natalia Muravleva, Associate Professor at the Faculty of Humanities, conducts her research. Her internship in Serbia continued her long-standing study of dialects spoken by Macedonian settlers. In this interview, she discusses how diaspora cultural centres help researchers reach informants, why native speakers need to be interviewed only in their own language (otherwise, as she puts it, they may 'break'), and how a single field season helped her finalise her monograph. She also shares warm memories of autumn in Belgrade and of colleagues with whom grammar can be discussed in three languages at once.

 

Have you spotted a typo?
Highlight it, click Ctrl+Enter and send us a message. Thank you for your help!

Publications
  • Books
  • Articles
  • Chapters of books
  • Working papers
  • Report a publication
  • Research at HSE

?

Are Mathematicians, Physicists and Biologists Irrational? Intransitivity Studies vs. the Transitivity Axiom

Human Arenas. An Interdisciplinary Journal of Psychology, Culture, and Meaning. 2026. Vol. 9. No. 2. P. 1262–1291.
Poddiakov A.

The status of the axioms of transitivity of dominance (“if x dominates y and y dominates z, then x dominates z” and “if a person prefers A to B and B to C, then that person should prefer A to C”) as key components of rationality is discussed. The discussion is conducted in the context of modern mathematical and natural science studies of systems in objectively intransitive (rock—paper—scissors) relations contradictory to the transitivity axioms. Experiential studies of solving problems about various intransitive objects and relations are described.

From an epistemological point of view, it seems reasonable to distinguish between 4 types of situations.

(1) Relations are objectively transitive, and problem solvers: (1a) make correct conclusions about them; or (1b) wrongly consider the relations as intransitive. Most cognitive studies are conducted in this paradigm.

(2) Relations are objectively intransitive, and problem solvers: (2a) make correct conclusions about them; or (2b) wrongly consider the relations as transitive (e.g., because of taking the transitivity axiom for granted). This has been minimally studied in cognitive psychology.

In general, for objectively transitive options, intransitive choices are fallacies. For objectively intransitive options, fallacies are transitive choices of the intransitive options.

Topological and graph theoretic approaches are more appropriate to present objectively intransitive objects and systems than metric approaches. Models of intransitive relations in biological studies are worthy of special interest in this context. Teaching intransitivity problem solving should be based on studies how abilities develop in this area and broader educational studies.

Research target: Mathematics Physics Biology Psychology Education
Language: English
Full text
DOI
Text on another site
Keywords: rationality problem solvingdecision makingtransitivity axiomintransitive objectscognition of complex systems
Similar publications
The Effect of the Gate Material in MIS Structures on the High-Field Charge Degradation in the Gate Dielectric
Andreev D. V., Kornev S. A., Bondarenko G.G. et al., Inorganic Materials: Applied Research 2026 Vol. 17 No. 5 P. 1226–1230
Comparative studies are carried out to investigate high-field charge degradation effects in the gate dielectric of metal—insulator—semiconductor (MIS) structures with aluminum and polysilicon gates. Charging phenomena in MIS structures are explored using high-field electron injection into the dielectric under conditions of gradually increasing voltage current density, with periodic short-term switching to a measurement mode at a constant low injection ...
Added: September 15, 2026
Validation of novel naturalistic limb movement stimuli for studying biological motion perception in adults
Koriakina M., Ntoumanis I., Blagoveshchensky E. et al., Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2026 Vol. 20 Article 1754368
Introduction:  Understanding how we perceive and interpret the movements of other living beings is fundamental to social interaction, survival, and navigating our dynamic environment. Traditional studies of biological motion perception have predominantly employed simplified stimuli, such as point-light displays, which sacrifice ecological validity for experimental control. Methods:  To overcome this limitation, we created a novel stimulus set featuring ...
Added: September 15, 2026
Vague stimulating ideas, images and metaphors in scientific thinking: researchers' work with horizons of unclear knowledge
Poddiakov A., / Series Social Science Research Network "Social Science Research Network". 2026. No. 7437658.
Clarity of knowledge and reasoning is necessary in many cases. Yet vagueness in scientific thinking related to surprise, curiosity, "ability to engage with not-knowing" (de Freitas) and abductive reasoning is also a crucially important source of scientific creativity which supplements combinatorial logic when dealing with the already known. Starting from studies by C. S. Peirce ...
Added: September 15, 2026
Water confined in heterogeneous clay–quartz pores: Structure and dynamics from atomistic simulations
Glushak A., Tararushkin E., Smirnov G., Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects 2027 Vol. 752 Article 141756
The molecular-scale behavior of water in heterogeneous clay–quartz systems is critical for understanding cementation processes in natural soils and compacted bentonite, which is crucial for oil recovery and nuclear waste disposal barriers construction. Here we investigate how heterogeneity of mixed Na-montmorillonite and α-quartz surfaces affect water structure and dynamics in nanopores of 2.5 to 60 Å ...
Added: September 15, 2026
The Social Mission of the University. Service-Learning, the Third Mission, and the Fifth-Generation University
Gaete Sepulveda M. A., Dymarskaya O. Y., Sosa Gómez G., Mexico: Centros Culturales de México, 2026.
Universities are called to respond to social fragility, the environmental crisis, technological transformation, artificial intelligence, and the loss of trust in institutions. This book argues that higher education cannot be limited to teaching, research, or technology transfer. Its deepest purpose is to contribute to the holistic human development of individuals, communities, and territories. By articulating the third mission, service-learning, and the Fifth ...
Added: September 15, 2026
Концептуализация феномена «присутствие» в пространстве консультативной работы с детьми-сиротами / Б. О. Вайдерман, А. В. Торопова // Мир психологии. – 2026. – № 3(126). – С. 4-19.
Торопова А. В., Vayderman B. O., Мир психологии. Научно-методический журнал 2026 № 3 С. 4–19
The article presents grounds for conceptualizing the phenomenon of “presence” in the space of counseling psychological work with orphaned children. Materials 5 of psychological sessions are presented, on the basis of which prerequisites for building the author’s conceptual model were identified. Deep phenomenological and hermeneutic research is based on the personological works of E. B. ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Some Aspects of Remote State Restoring in State Transfer Governed by XXZ-Hamiltonian
Bochkin G., Doronin S., Fel’dman E. et al., Lobachevskii Journal of Mathematics 2024 Vol. 45 No. 3 P. 1188–1207
We consider the remote state restoring and perfect transfer of the zero-order coherence matrix (PTZ) in a spin system governed by the XXZ-Hamiltonian conserving the excitation number. The restoring tool is represented by several nonzero Larmor frequencies in the Hamiltonian. To simplify the analysis we use two approximating models including either step-wise or pulse-type time-dependence ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Coherence restoring in communication line via controlled interaction with environment
Fel’dman E. B., Lazarev I., Pechen A. N. et al., Quantum Information Processing 2026 Vol. 25 Article 121
We consider the state-restoring protocol based on the controlled interaction of a linear chain with environment through incoherent control by the specially adjusted step-wise time-dependent Lindblad operators. We show that the best restoring result (maximal scale factors in the restored state) corresponds to the symmetrical Lindblad equation. (0, 1)-excitation dynamics is considered numerically, and restoring ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Macroscopic entanglement distribution with atomic ensembles
Li S., Hu J., Lazarev I. et al., Annals of Physics 2026 Vol. 494 Article 170618
The distribution of entanglement is a crucial task for quantum communication towards realizing a globe-spanning quantum internet. Recently, a protocol for deterministic long-distance distribution of macroscopic entanglement over a network of ensembles of qubits was introduced (Pyrkov et al., 2025). It was shown that this protocol allows for the propagation of macroscopic amounts of entanglement ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Quantum Repeater Protocol for Deterministic Distribution of Macroscopic Entanglement, Advanced Quantum Technologies
Pyrkov A., Lazarev I., Byrnes T., Advanced Quantum Technologies 2025 Article 2400524
Distributing long-distance entanglement is a fundamental goal that is necessary for a variety of tasks such as quantum communication, distributed quantum computing, and quantum metrology. Currently quantum repeater schemes typically aim to distribute one ebit at a time, the equivalent of one Bell pair's worth of entanglement. Here, a scheme is presented to distribute a ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Hybrid quantum-classical unsupervised data clustering based on the self-organizing feature map
I. D. Lazarev, Narozniak M., Byrnes T. et al., Physical Review A: Atomic, Molecular, and Optical physics 2025 Vol. 111 No. 012416 Article 012416
Unsupervised machine learning is one of the main techniques employed in artificial intelligence. We introduce an algorithm for quantum-assisted unsupervised data clustering using the self-organizing feature map, a type of artificial neural network. The complexity of our algorithm scales as 𝑂⁡(𝐿⁢𝑁), in comparison to the classical case which scales as 𝑂⁡(𝐿⁢𝑀⁢𝑁), where 𝑁 is the ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Mixing of real and quantum gases
Борщевский А. Я., Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2025 Vol. 27 No. 9 P. 4793–4803
Through the consistent application of quantum statistical thermodynamics, functions of isothermal mixing of real rarefied gases and quantum gases in states of varying degrees of degeneracy are obtained. The reasons for the emergence and resolution of the “Gibbs paradox” and other “paradoxes” are analyzed. Numerical calculations of entropy and pressure jumps were performed using the ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Cyber-Creativity: A Decalogue of Research Challenges
Corazza G. E., Agnoli S., Kharkhurin, A. V. et al., Journal of Intelligence 2025 Vol. 13 No. 8 Article 103
Creativity is the primary driver of our cultural evolution. The astonishing potential of artificial intelligence (AI) and its possible application in the creative process poses an urgent and dramatic challenge for humanity; how can we maximize the benefits of AI while minimizing the associated risks? In this article, we identify all forms of human–AI collaboration ...
Added: September 14, 2026
The authenticity gap: Why generative AI cannot replicate human creativity
Kharkhurin, A. V., Corazza G. E., JOURNAL OF CREATIVITY 2026 Vol. 36 No. 3 Article 100132
This article examines whether generative artificial intelligence (Gen-AI) can be considered creative when evaluated through a dynamic cross-cultural framework of creativity. Integrating the dynamic model of creativity (Corazza et al., 2022) with the four-criterion construct of creativity (Kharkhurin, 2014), the analysis evaluates Gen-AI across four dimensions: originality, effectiveness, aesthetics, and authenticity. The article advances the ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Факторы успешной социально-психологической адаптации женщин, заключивших брак с иностранцами
Mironova O. I., Руонала Л. А., М.: МПГУ им. Ленина, 2026.
Монография посвящена факторам успешной социально-психологической адаптации женщин, переехавших в другу ю страну в связи с замужеством. Особое внимание уделяется рассмотрению феномена адаптации как динамического и нелинейного процесса, влияющего на эволюцию представлений личности о собственной идентичности. В работе подчеркивается важность анализа не только явных, осознаваемых аспектов адаптации, но и скрытых факторов, влияющих на включение в новое ...
Added: September 14, 2026
Экономические основы рациональности и эффективности государственных субсидий коммерческим организациям
Ключников И. К., Saakyan T. V., Финансовый журнал 2025 Т. 17 № 1 С. 74–91
Subject. Rationality and efficiency of budgeting state subsidies to business entities. Objectives. To develop a science-based system for assessing the rationality and effectiveness of the process of state subsidization of business entities. Results. The interrelation of rationality and efficiency of the process of budgeting subsidies to business entities is substantiated. Determination of the logic of ...
Added: June 1, 2026
Эмпирический анализ читинга среди студентов разных университетов
Кырма В. В., Орлова Е. О., Rozmainsky I. V., Журнал институциональных исследований 2025 Т. 17 № 3 С. 136–156
In this paper, we conducted a study of the prevalence of cheating among university students and analyzed the factors contributing to this phenomenon. Cheating is a form of opportunism, when an individual chooses a strategy to achieve success through deception, manipulation, or forgery. The research was carried out on the basis of a survey created ...
Added: October 8, 2025
Intelligent and Fuzzy Systems: Artificial Intelligence in Human-Centric, Resilient and Sustainable Industries, Proceedings of the INFUS 2025 Conference, Volume 4
Springer Publishing Company, 2025.
This book focuses on benefiting artificial intelligent tools in our business and social life under emerging conditions. Human-centric, resilient, and sustainable industries are built on ideals like human-centricity, ecological advantages, or social benefits. The mission of human-centric artificial intelligence is to improve people’s lives by offering solutions that boost productivity, accessibility to resources, security, well-being, ...
Added: July 31, 2025
Emerging Adults’ Autonomy in Romantic Narrative Identities: Choices Between Emotions and Rationality
Victoria G. Yerofeyeva, Ekaterina M. Tsyganova, Bochaver A. A., Trends in Psychology 2025
This study examines how emerging adults define autonomy through their roman tic relationship choices. Emerging adulthood provides a lot of opportunities to try different things, but the diversity of alternatives makes it difficult to choose. Under these conditions, autonomy becomes a necessary personal characteristic. We set out to examine how young people construct romantic narratives identities based on the characteristics ...
Added: July 25, 2025
Editorial
Panos Pardalos, Valery Kalyagin, Mario R. Guarracino, Computational Management Science 2024 Vol. 21 No. 1 Article 35
Big data has become an integral part of modern networks. With the increasing amount of data generated by devices, machines, and applications, networks are constantly being challenged to handle and process this data in a timely and efficient manner. The size, complexity, and variety of data in networks are increasing rapidly, which requires new approaches ...
Added: February 22, 2025
Культурно-историческая эпистемология: философские разговоры: К юбилею Бориса Исаевича Пружинина
Azhimov F., Pruzhinin B. I., Zhukova O. et al., М.: РОССПЭН, 2024.
Коллективная монография, посвященная 80-летию известного российского философа-эпистемолога Б. И. Пружинина, представляет основные тематические векторы его творчества – наука, рациональность, эпистемологический стиль русской философии, многообразие культур – на пересечении мнений, высказанных российскими и зарубежными философами (коллегами и друзьями юбиляра) на круглых столах. Стержневой темой публикуемых дискуссий стала концепция культурно-исторической эпистемологии: участники обсуждали ее философско-методологический потенциал в ...
Added: January 14, 2025
Обращаясь к содержанию: теоретические предпосылки исследования уровней абстракции понятия в решении проблемно ориентированных задач
Andronova E., Мир психологии. Научно-методический журнал 2024 № 4(119) С. 133–145
While numerous studies have explored conceptual structure and its role in learning, few have delved into the content characteristics of concepts themselves. Even fewer have investigated how these content characteristics relate to the broader learning process, especially problem solving. This paper focuses on one such characteristic — levels of abstraction — and offers a theoretical ...
Added: December 24, 2024
«Архитекторы Франсафрик»? Экспертно-аналитическое обеспечение современной политики Франции в Африке
Degterev D. A., Абрамова Е. А., Современная Европа 2024 № 5(126) С. 74–87
The ongoing foreign policy failures of France in Africa, primarily in the countries of the Sahel zone, force us to pay special attention to the mechanisms of decision-making in this area, which is the focus of this paper. A key place is given to the role of the academic community in the foreign policy expertise ...
Added: November 19, 2024
Intelligent and Fuzzy Systems: Intelligent Industrial Informatics and Efficient Networks Proceedings of the INFUS 2024 Conference, Volume 1
Springer, 2024.
This book presents recent research in intelligent and fuzzy techniques on Intelligent Industrial Informatics and Efficient Networks. This cutting-edge field integrates advanced technologies, such as artificial intelligence, machine learning and data analytics, into industrial processes, revolutionizing the way industries operate. The book presents the examples of the implementation of smart sensors and IoT devices, which ...
Added: September 14, 2024
  • About
  • About
  • Key Figures & Facts
  • Sustainability at HSE University
  • Faculties & Departments
  • International Partnerships
  • Faculty & Staff
  • HSE Buildings
  • HSE University for Persons with Disabilities
  • Public Enquiries
  • Studies
  • Admissions
  • Programme Catalogue
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Exchange Programmes
  • Summer University
  • Summer Schools
  • Semester in Moscow
  • Business Internship
  • Research
  • International Laboratories
  • Research Centres
  • Research Projects
  • Monitoring Studies
  • Conferences & Seminars
  • Academic Jobs
  • Yasin (April) International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development
  • Media & Resources
  • Publications by staff
  • HSE Journals
  • Publishing House
  • iq.hse.ru: commentary by HSE experts
  • Library
  • Economic & Social Data Archive
  • Video
  • HSE Repository of Socio-Economic Information
  • HSE1993–2026
  • Contacts
  • Copyright
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Map
Edit