No right to remain silent? In search of equality in the field

Ch. 9. P. 189–200.

Omelchenko E. L.

The ethnographic tradition in which this research was conducted requires the nurturing of close and trusting relations between researchers and respondents. Building and maintaining this level of closeness, it transpired, also demanded significant emotional labour from all those involved since it meant overcoming the mistrust and inequality that haunt the research process. We addressed this by modelling our relations with respondents on the everyday practices of the group itself. We also tried to move beyond a purely formal commitment to ‘equality’ in our relations by recognising the equal right of the respondents to question and ‘research’ us. Adopting such an approach, however, had an unanticipated consequence; our interlocutors persistently expected ‘something extra’ from us and, through tests and provocations but also demonstrations of affection, turned the research process on its head, making themselves the agents and us the dependents in the research relationship

Keywords: социальные группы, молодежные культуры, национализм, ксенофобия, скинхеды, nationalism, методология исследования, youth culture, социологическое исследование, xenophobia, sociological study, skinheads, research methodology, social groups

In book

Russia’s Skinheads: exploring and rethinking subcultural lives

Pilkington H., Omelchenko E. L., Garifzianova A. L., NY: Routledge, 2010.