?
Political And Legal Views Of Mikhail Speranskiy In “Rules On The Siberian Kirghiz”
Высшая школа экономики
,
2014.
No. 43.
Mikhail Speranskiy, outstanding Russian statesman and legislator of the first half of the 19th century was the Siberian Governor-General from 1819-1821. The main result of this stage in his career was the reform of government in Asiatic Russia as well as development in 1822 of a set of codes – rules and regulations – for Siberia and its peoples. Speranskiy tried to incorporate his theoretical views on the state and law into these codifications. One of them were the “Rules on the Siberian Kirghiz” which provided reforms of the government system of Kazakhs (“Kirghiz” in the Russian pre-revolutionary tradition) of the Middle Horde which were under the control of Siberian regional authorities. The Middle Horde became a place for practical experimentation for Speranskiy’s ideas. Previous researchers have paid more attention to consequences of the promulgation of the “Rules on the Siberian Kirghiz” on the further history of Kazakhstan. This paper clarifies which specific ideas of Speranskiy on the state and law were reflected in the “Rules on the Siberian Kirghiz” and answers the question of whether they had practical importance. A substantial part of the “Rules on the Siberian Kirghiz” was, in fact, ineffective and didn’t use in practice because of lack of knowledge of Speranskiy on Kazakhs and his underestimation of their political and legal level. At the same time, authority of Speranskiy in the Russia of the 19th c. as legislator and reformer was so high that his “Rules on the Siberian Kirghiz” became actual until 1860s when next substantial reforms in Kazakhstan took place.
Language:
English
Keywords: Российская империяhistory of the Russian EmpireM.M.Speransky's sociopolitical philosophyсоциально-политическая философия М.М. Сперанскоготрадиционное правоImperial legislationимперское законодательствоlegal reform in Kazakhstan in XIX centuryправовая реформа в Казахстане в XIX в.М.М. Сперанскийtraditional lawtraditions and modernizationRules on the Siberian KirghizУстав о сибирских киргизахтрадиции и модернизация
Pochekaev R. Y., Гражданское общество в России и за рубежом 2015 № 1 С. 27-31
Frontier authorities of the Russian Empire in Kazakhstan and Turkestan paid a lot of attention to a problem of improvement of rights of women and its broadening. Legal mechanisms of this process firstly provided more rights of women in family life as well as opportunities of defending their rights at courts (particularly, by appealing of ...
Added: April 26, 2015
Pochekaev R. Y., Гасырлар авазы - Эхо веков 2016 № 3/4 С. 237-242
В статье анализируются сведения чиновника администрации Оренбургского края М. Аитова о государственности и праве Казахстана и ханств Средней Азии. ...
Added: December 16, 2016
Pochekaev R. Y., Евразия, 2017
В книге исследуются взаимоотношения России (Московской Руси - Московского царства - Российской империи) с наследниками Улуса Джучи (Золотой Орды). Различные тюрко-монгольские государства, возникшие в результате распада Золотой Орды, просуществовали разное время: одни утратили самостоятельность уже в XVI в. (Казанское и Астраханское ханства), другие просуществовали до XVIII-XIX вв. (Крымское и Казахское ханства). И каждому из них ...
Added: September 16, 2017
Pochekaev R. Y., Pax Islamica 2015 № 1
Article devoted to the problem of rivalry between the Russian Empire and Khivan Khanate on the control of Kazakhstan in the 19th c. and legal aspects of its solving. Over a long period of time confronting sides attempted to extend own taxation system on Kazakhs. At that Khivan authorities staked on traditional law and common ...
Added: November 29, 2014
Pochekaev R. Y., Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Юридические науки 2017 Т. 21 № 4 С. 508-527
Goal. Article devoted to analysis of information and evaluations of the members of the Bukharan elite of the 1870s — 1910s on legal transformations made by Russian authorities in the Bukharan Emirate which since 1868 was under the protectorate of the Russian Empire. Author used works of contemporaries — Bukharan officials who were loyal to ...
Added: January 27, 2018
Pochekaev R. Y., Народы и религии Евразии 2019 № 4 С. 7-16
The punishment of powerful leaders of Kiyat-Jurkin tribe Sacha-Beki and his brother Taychu by their relative Chinggis Khan was fixed in many sources (Mongolian, Chinese, Persian). Their analysis allows to find differences not only in factual, but also in ideological aspect. As a result, in earlier sources execution of relatives by Chinggis Khan is covertly blamed, whereas in works ...
Added: December 1, 2019
Pochekaev R. Y., Вопросы правоведения 2015 № 4 С. 195-203
Article devoted to the problem of rivalry between the Russian Empire and Khivan Khanate on the control of Kazakhstan in the 19th c. and legal aspects of its solving. Over a long period of time confronting sides attempted to extend own taxation system on Kazakhs. At that Khivan authorities staked on traditional law and common ...
Added: November 16, 2015
Pochekaev R. Y., Вопросы истории и археологии Западного Казахстана 2011 № 1 С. 57-75
В статье дана характеристика правовой ситуации в Казахстане в период его нахождения в составе Российской империи – с административной и судебной реформ конца 1860-х гг. до падения Российской империи. В этот период российские власти пытались сформировать в Казахстане особую правовую систему, в рамках которой принципы имперского права легитимировались путем инкорпорации в институты традиционного казахского права ...
Added: December 22, 2012
Pochekaev R. Y., Quaestio Rossica 2020 Vol. 8 No. 4 P. 1450-1460
In his monograph The Burden of the Empire. The Administrative Policy of Russia in Central Asia. Second Half of the 19th Century, D. V. Vasilyev analyses imperial Russian policy in the region, focusing on the administration of the steppe provinces and Russian Turkestan between 1865 and 1891. This approach allows the author to observe the evolution of views of ...
Added: November 27, 2020
Pochekaev R. Y., Восток. Афро-азиатские общества: история и современность 2018 № 3 С. 51-63
The article examines legal developments of the Khanates of Bukhara and Khiva in the first half of the nineteenth century as they reflected by Russian and British travellers who visited these states during the period under review. In these times, the contacts of the European states with Bukhara and Khiva did increase, and the Europeans, mostly Russian and ...
Added: July 6, 2018
Pochekaev R. Y., Отан тарихы - Отечественная история 2016 № 3 С. 42-53
Article devoted to analysis of information of Chokan Valikhanov on political and legal system of Eastern Turkestan (Xingjian) gathered during his trips to this region in 1856 and 1858-1859. He examined traditional political and legal system, changes made by Qing administration, Special attention paid to political and legal structure of so called state of khojas ...
Added: December 16, 2016
Pochekaev R. Y., Отан тарихы - Отечественная история 2014 № 3 С. 5-16
This article is devoted to formal legal features of first stage of entering Kazakhstan into Russian Empire. Author comes to conclusion that legalization of taking the Russian suzerainty by khan Abulkhair combined ancient traditions of relations between Moscow and nomadic peoples as well as new imperial legal practices. As a result, there was some uncertainty ...
Added: November 15, 2014
Pochekaev R. Y., Вестник Волгоградского государственного университета. Серия 4: История. Регионоведение. Международные отношения 2020 Т. 25 № 5 С. 42-51
The aim of the paper is to study the notes of the participants of Russian naval expeditions to the east coast of the Caspian Sea since the middle of 18th to the second half of 19th c. as a source of information on the political and legal position of local Turkmen tribes. Another aim is to analyze ...
Added: November 22, 2020
Pochekaev R. Y., Отан тарихы - Отечественная история 2016 № 4 С. 158-167
В статье анализируются сведения российских путешественников о Ташкенте в период его существования как независимого государства (XVII- начало XIX вв.). Особое внимание уделяется политическому положению и правовому развитию "владения". ...
Added: January 18, 2017
Pochekaev R. Y., Вестник Пермского университета. Серия: История 2019 № 2 С. 14-23
The history of Mongolia in the 17th – early 20th centuries is covered mostly in the notes of Russian travelers and
scholars, whereas their Western colleagues did not visit the country often. That is why their information on different
aspects of the life of Mongols including its political and legal culture is of great value. The author ...
Added: July 15, 2019
Pochekaev R. Y., Золотоордынское обозрение 2020 Т. 8 № 1 С. 51-66
Objective: A study of the Golden Horde historical sources of the midfourteenth century containing information on the history of law and trials in the Golden Horde, providing a comparison of the actions of the Golden Horde authorities with similar actions taken in other countries of that time. This includes a general assessment of the standards of the Golden Horde ...
Added: March 29, 2020
Pochekaev R. Y., Крымское историческое обозрение 2015 № 1 С. 120-145
Article devoted to analysis of political activity of Uzbek khan Muhammad Sheybany and Crimean khan Muhammad Girey I at the beginning of the 16th c. Author examines politics of two khans using historical-legal approach and concentrated on analysis of administrative system established by both monarchs, their relations with other rulers of former Golden Horde territories. ...
Added: June 17, 2015
Pochekaev R. Y., Средневековые тюрко-татарские государства 2011 № 3 С. 112-127
Статья посвящена политико-правовым аспектам истории Касимовского и Букеевского ханств, которые в разное время, но изначально возникли как вассалы Российского государства. Автор сравнивает эти государства, выясняя, насколько широко в них применялись чингизидское право и российское законодательство. ...
Added: December 22, 2012
Pochekaev R. Y., Общество и государство в Китае 2016 Т. 46 № 2 С. 531-542
В статье анализируется система управления, созданная российскими имперскими властями в Илийском крае в период его временного пребывания в составе России в 1871-1881 гг., оценивается степень сохранения традиционных институтов управления и нововведений в связи с изменением статуса региона. ...
Added: January 17, 2017
Pochekaev R. Y., Гражданское общество в России и за рубежом 2015 № 3 С. 41-44
Frontier authorities of the Russian Empire in their relations with Central Asian khanates paid a lot of attention to problem of improvement of women’s rights, their broadening as well as to protection of interests of women with Russian citizenship who lived in Central Asian states. The policy of “emancipation” had a goal not to improve ...
Added: September 15, 2015
Pochekaev R. Y., Eurasia: Statum et Legem (Евразия: государство и право) 2016 № 6 С. 76-87
В статье анализируются сведения российских военных исследователей, посетивших Монголию в конце XIX в., о праве и правоотношениях этой страны. Рассматриваются нашедшие в них отражение особенности адми-нистративно-правового регулирования, налоговой системы, уголовных, про-цессуальных, частноправовых отношений. Ценность записок российских оче-видцев состоит в том, что они имели дело с принципами и нормами права, не просто зафиксированными в правовых актах ...
Added: January 18, 2017
Pochekaev R. Y., Вестник Оренбургского государственного педагогического университета. Электронный научный журнал 2023 № 3(47) С. 245-255
The article is a research of a case of sultan Kaigali Ishimov of the Inner Horde (Bukey Khanate) who attempted to migrate to the Junior Jhuz in 1829, but was arrested by Orenburg authorities and prosecuted. The author analyses the investigation of Kaipgali’s case, the means and methods of finding the evidence, the position of ...
Added: November 18, 2023
Pochekaev R. Y., Алматы : Абди компани, 2018
В книге освещаются актуальные вопросы формирования и развития права и становления «человека юридического», эволюции его отношения к власти и праву. Впервые базовые принципы и понятия юридической антропологии, основные этапы «правогенеза» прослеживаются на основе анализа политико-правовых реалий тюрко-монгольских народов Евразии. Рассматриваются основные стадии развития представлений о власти и праве у кочевых народов, выявляются тенденции формирования системы традиционного права и его источников, анализируется роль ...
Added: April 28, 2018
Pochekaev R. Y., Письменные памятники Востока 2016 Т. 13 № 4 С. 109-117
The article is an attempt to appreciate the role and importance of works of the outstanding Russian orientalist O.F. Akimushkin on history of the Eastern Turkestan (Kashgaria) in the view if study of state and law of this region. Although the scholar didn’t concentrated on problems of political and legal development of the Eastern Turkestan, ...
Added: February 4, 2017