Государство и бизнес в арбитражном процессе

Вопросы экономики. 2014. № 6. С. 40–62.

Dzmitryieva A., Chetverikova I., Titaev K. D.

This article seeks to answer the question whether Russian Arbitrazh
(Commercial) courts tend to decide cases in favor of defendant versus plaintiff
or state versus business. It was found that courts favors business entities in civil
cases, while in administrative cases courts take decisions in favor of governmental
bodies other things being equal. In addition, the plaintiff bias persists regardless
of the type of the process. However, the plaintiff bias decreases with the rise of
the case complexity. The article is based on the regression analysis of a random
sample of 10 000 cases decided by the Russian Arbitrazh (commercial) courts
in 2007—2011.

Keywords: economic institutions, арбитражные суды, государство и бизнес, arbitrazh court, empirical legal studies, business government litigation, эмпирические исследования права, институты российской экономики