?
Some Reflections about Unity of Law and of Normative Systems
P. 35–46.
This paper aims to analyse the philosophical premises on which the idea of unity of law (identity of legal system) is based. In the history of legal philosophy this idea found its main arguments in the presumption of totality of legal regulation. Such totality translated the philosophical tenets of holism according to which law is not limited to the positive-law rules and institutes. To substantiate the idea of systemacity of law, one can turn to the modern debates about logic of social cohesion and construct a legal system identity as a purely intellectual hypothesis necessary for thinking about law. This integrity can be described as a unity of discourse, or as a unity of societal practices. This reconstruction of integrity of law can be extended by appealing to the basic ideas of normative philosophy of law (from Hart and Kelsen to Raz and Dworkin) and is reconcilable with the conception of normative systems of Bulygin–Alchourron.
Publication based on the results of:
In book
Buenos Aires: Faculty of Law of Buenos Aires University, 2014.
Lisanyuk E., Шапиро О. А., Философия науки 2025 № 6(110) С. 89–101
We present the result of a case-study of reasoning in a dispute using formal-logical and qualitative methods of analysis that model demonstrative and non-demonstrative argumentation. This approach allows us to overcome the limitations of descriptive and normative methods of studying judicial argumentation used in isolation and to reconstruct the essence of a judicial dispute in ...
Added: March 5, 2026
Osipova P., Churakov V., Vinogradov S. et al., Социология власти 2025 Т. 37 № 4 С. 215–248
The purpose of the study is to identify the elements and characteristics of the interaction of Brian Tamanaha’s normative systems for a more detailed analysis of the intersection of social orders. The research uses interviews collected during two expeditions to North Ossetia. Based on the results of coding interviews collected by the authors in August ...
Added: December 21, 2025
Lisanyuk E., Perova N., , in: 2025 IEEE Ural-Siberian Conference on Biomedical Engineering, Radioelectronics and Information Technology (USBEREIT), 12-13 May 2025.: IEEE, 2025. P. 41–44.
The development of e-justice and implementation of institution-based procedures for the resolution of ethical conflicts open a perspective of e-morality, both as a separate field, and as a tool of eliminating the digital divide, created by e-justice. We observe five restrictions for organizing future automated emorality analogously to contemporary automation of e-justice and explain why ...
Added: August 18, 2025
Tikhomirov Y., Право и экономика 2018 № 11 С. 5–9
В мире происходят сложные и противоречивые процессы развития права. Увеличение правовых массивов и усложнение их восприятия и использования побуждают к разработке новой концепции сравнительного правоведения. Ее отмечает анализ более широкого понимания правовых семей ("кочующих" и в рамках международных объединений), введение в оборот понятий: "правовое пространство и границы","правовой суверенитет", "разновекторность развития права", "координация правовых решений общемировых ...
Added: January 30, 2019
Antonov M., Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki 2015 No. 2 P. 148–165
This paper aims to analyse the philosophical premises on which the idea of unity of law (the identity of legal systems) is based. In the history of legal philosophy, this idea found its main arguments in the presumption of totality of legal regulation. Such totality affected the philosophical tenets of holism, according to which law ...
Added: August 26, 2015
Antonov M., Russian Law Journal 2015 Vol. 3 No. 3 P. 110–125
The subject-matter of this article is the ‘systemacity of law’ concept and its methodological feedback. Continuing a series of articles on this subject, the author focuses on the internal rationality of claims about the systemic character of law. This rationality is embedded in the legal thinking of Modernity and reveals itself in the belief in ...
Added: August 25, 2015
Antonov M., / NRU Higher School of Economics. Series LAW "Law". 2015.
The subject-matter of this article is the “systemacity of law” concept and its methodological feedback. Continuing a series of articles on this subject, the author focuses on the internal rationality of claims about systemic character of law. This rationality is embedded in the legal thinking of Modernity and reveals itself in the belief in rational ...
Added: March 2, 2015
Erokhina Y., Право и жизнь 2014 № 197 (11) С. 56–72
Актуальность темы обусловлена наличием множества противоречивых мнений о рассматриваемой проблеме, различных факторах и условиях возникновения конфликтов (экономических, правовых, политических, социальных и др.). Постмодернистический подход предусматривает иные формы взаимодействия общества и государства, в отличие от модернистического представления о технологиях управления обществом, строящихся на строго детерминистической основе. Характерной чертой постмодернистов является их оппозиционность ко всему, от чего ...
Added: March 1, 2015
Bulygin E., , in: Коммуникативная теория права и современные проблемы юриспруденцииТ. 2: Актуальные проблемы философии права и юридической науки в связи с коммуникативной теорией права.: СПб.: Алеф-Пресс, 2014. P. 33–39.
In this article Professor Bulygin analyzes rationality of law in the light of legal positivism ...
Added: January 15, 2015
Antonov M., Arts and Social Sciences Journal 2014 Vol. 5 No. 2
This paper aims to analyse the philosophical premises on which the idea of unity of law (identity of legal system)
is based. In the history of legal philosophy this idea found its main arguments in the presumption of totality of legal
regulation. Such totality translated the philosophical tenets of holism according to which law is not limited ...
Added: December 18, 2014
Erokhina Y., Право. Журнал Высшей школы экономики 2014 № 4 С. 19–29
Актуальность обусловлена необходимостью понимания происходящих в правовой науке изменений, суть которых заключается в том, что наше восприятие реальности основывается на научных парадигмах. Мир представляется как место, полное противоречий и беспорядка, и мы ищем такие рамки, которые наполнят его смыслом. Многие исследователи широко используют понятия и методы синергетики, которая в американской научной литературе чаще всего носит ...
Added: October 25, 2014
Erokhina Y., Адвокат 2014 № 12 С. 13–19
Исследование правового постмодернизма в России позволяет решить проблему осмысления трансформации правовых процессов, происходивших в нашей стране, которая находилась в ситуации глобального кризиса во всех сферах жизнежеятельности: политике, экономике, культуре. Изучение феномена постмодерна и его возможных проявлений актуально для целого ряда нацчных дисциплин, а именно философии, политологии, антропологии и др. Между тем скурпулезное внимание со стороны ...
Added: October 25, 2014
Antonov M., В кн.: Проблемы философии и методологии права.: Самара: Самарская гуманитарная академия, 2014. С. 47–57.
In the present paper the author examines the problem of systemacity of law, analyzes the ways in which the normative material is structured. Basing on the conception of normative systems by C. Alchourron and E. Bugygin, the author criticizes some assertions made by Russian legal theoreticians about systemacity of law and calls for a more ...
Added: October 9, 2014
Mexico: Consejo editorial, H. Cámara de dipuados, 2013.
Added: August 26, 2014
Antonov M., , in: Philisophy of Law International Symposium "Rationality in Law".: Buenos Aires: Faculty of Law of Buenos Aires University, 2014. P. 21–34.
This paper aims to analyse the philosophical premises on which the idea of unity of law (identity of legal system) is based. In the history of legal philosophy this idea found its main arguments in the presumption of totality of legal regulation. Such totality translated the philosophical tenets of holism according to which law is ...
Added: May 19, 2014