• A
  • A
  • A
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • ABC
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
  • А
Regular version of the site
Of all publications in the section: 71
Sort:
by name
by year
Article
Didikin A. Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2014. No. 4. P. 26-32.

The paper presents an analysis of the discussion about naturalization of epistemology in the analytic legal philosophy

Added: Feb 16, 2018
Article
Chiarvesio F. Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2020. No. 58. P. 198-205.

The literature on anti-corruption in Russia is characterized by the prevalence of broad studies and a lack of infield research. This paper illustrates the need to expand the research focus and to investigate the processes taking place within civil society. By focusing on neglections, this work proposes new research approaches.

Added: Nov 28, 2020
Article
Lisanyuk E. Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2019. No. 48. P. 193-204.

In The Karamazov Brothers, Dostoevsky tells a story of a judicial error. Dmitry Karamazov, accused of murdering his father Feodor Karamazov whom he did not kill, was found guilty of the murder and sent to Siberia. The Dmitry Karamazov case is relevant to the contemporary discussion of the role legal argumentation plays with respect to the conceptions of truth inherent in two models of judiciary, investigative (inquisitional) and competitive (adversarial), on which the evaluation of the parties’ arguments is based. The authors examine the reasons of the judicial error – the prosecutor’s biased conviction, his derailments in justifying his version of a crime, the jurors’ wrong assessment of the parties’ argumentation, and the shortcomings of the newly introduced adversarial process type – and argue that the truth can and should be established in both of them, and that the three conceptions of truth (referential, inferential and pragmatic) play an evaluative role in that. They serve as the necessary tools in evaluation of the court’s and the parties’ perfection in performing their obligations in the courtroom as they demonstrate whether the epistemological ideal of the material truth was sufficiently pursued for establishing the truth and fair decision. The Dmitry Karamazov case shows that the formal view of the truth suffices for deciding a case, but it cannot prevent judicial errors that occur when such an ideal falls into oblivion.

Added: Oct 12, 2020
Article
Antonov M. Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2019. Vol. 48. P. 173-185.

Lawyers work with statements about verisimilitude of factual statements, while trustworthiness of these statements is evaluated against the backdrop of coherence of factual descriptions. A correct conclusion in law means a consistent reconstruction of normative meanings in the way that fits best the normative system and that allows to cogently subsume factual states of affairs under the established normative meanings.

Added: May 29, 2019
Article
Ярская-Смирнова Е. Р., Ярская В. Н. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2020. № 56. С. 223-234.

In modern Russia, despite many significant changes, the physical and social isolation of people with disabilities remains. However, people are increasingly manifesting themselves as active actors advocating in public space for the inclusion and accessibility of cities. Urban public space is a space located and created between people through speech and action. The authors refer to agency as an indi-vidual’s ability to the socially important, political speaking and action. It appears if a person is visible, capable and willing to interact with others, to take on the initiative, be motivated not only by one’s own interests, but also by the worldly attachment. The authors show what problems people with disa-bilities and other citizens face, what experience they gain in trying to find themselves in public spaces, to activate communication, and take on the initiative in collective interests. The article is based on Hannah Arendt’s ideas that the authors apply to the analysis of 40 qualitative interviews collected in the summer of 2019 in Kazan, Samara, Saratov, and Tomsk with local experts—activists, including ten interviews in the walk-along methodology. The study showed that public space is created as a web of connections and meanings between people in the interaction regarding the designation of their identity, communication with others, and initiatives on socially important issues. The performance of identity fills the space of communications with new emotions and meanings and is accompanied by various reactions of others. Thus, the scope and formats of publicity are changing, the space becomes more open and inclusive. Participation in public space does not automatically lead to a reduction in inequali-ty or an increase in the accessibility of urban space. In the conditions when new social norms are not internalized by the majority of surrounders, institutions and other actors are needed to facilitate the participation of the less powerful in public space.

Added: Oct 16, 2020
Article
Бедаш Ю. А. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2014. № 4 (16). С. 211-218.

There are two phenomenological paradigms in space analysis: body-oriented paradigm (Edmund Husserl and Maurice Merleau-Ponty) and world-oriented one (Martin Heidegger). In this article we will consider key features of the body-oriented paradigm, shortly  examining its relationships with the world-oriented one. Husserl and Merleau-Ponty refuse to understand space metaphysically, i.e. as an abstract object uprooted from the life world and acting subject. Their post-metaphysical understanding of space begins with the analysis of constitutive role of  human body as a "zero point" setting system of coordinates for human orientation in the world. This creative aspect of  human body (incarnated consciousness) reveals within the analysis of spatial thing perception (E.Husserl) and intersubjective dimension of body experience (M. Merleau-Ponty).

Added: Jan 19, 2015
Article
Лисанюк Е. Н., Воеводин Н. М. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2018. № 42. С. 25-42.

To treat or not to treat hopelessly ill patients? Not to treat, Plato answers in The Republic, since for this decision it is sufficient that the doctor knows his patient as incurable. To treat, says Aristotle in The Rhetoric, since for this decision it is sufficient that the doctor knows of the possibility to return his patient’s health. The authors show that these Plato’s and Aristotle’s explicit answers reflect their positions only partly, and under certain conditions they imply the opposite answers, too. The authors discuss the issue of passive euthanasia as the doctor’s refusal to treat hopelessly ill patients from two angles: from the viewpoint of this practice in ancient societies, and from that of practical argumentation regarding actions by means of which the decisions over patients’ euthanasia are justified. As concerns euthanasia practices, there are three features characterizing ancient societies: such decisions rest on the epistemic grounds, they employ a paternalistic approach to doctor-patient relations and a functional view on what health is. Therefore, the goal of medical treatment is solely the return of health, and no palliative care corresponds to it; it is his knowledge that enables the doctor to euthanize, and no patient’s consent is required. In its full-fledged form, Plato’s answer is: not to treat, if and only if the doctor knows about the incurable condition of the patient, and to treat if the doctor knows that the Аргументация в начале эвтаназии 41 patient can be cured. Since the conclusions in practical arguments are plausible and defeasible, they amplify the rigid framework of the dichotomy in Plato’s argument “from virtue” which erects doctor’s knowledge to a professional virtue understood as his contribution to the well-being of society performed by treating those who deserve that and refusing to do so with those hopelessly ill. Doctor’s knowledge is essential in Aristotle’s argument “from patient”, according to which a hopelessly ill patient has to be treated if and only if the doctor considers his treatment possible, and not treated if he thinks otherwise. The doctor determines the possibility of treatment with the help of a practical syllogism, outlined by Aristotle in The Nicomachean Ethics. In this reasoning the doctor determines a line of conduct with respect to the goal of returning health to his patient, and he has to refrain from treating the patient if no such line can be determined.

Added: Oct 10, 2020
Article
Лисанюк Е. Н., Перова Н. В. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2021. № 59. С. 278-289.
Added: Aug 20, 2021
Article
Горбатова Ю. В. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2016. № 2(34). С. 53-60.

The article “God as a Theoretical Object, or About Ontological Status of God Again” consist of introduction, four general parts, and conclusion. In introduction author tells about t way of investigation, which comes her to writing the article.

The first part of research “Brief introduction in history of problem” describes a situation in the middle of XXth century. In 60s arises a new strong interest to God’s existence proves since the possible world semantics has been formulated by Saul Kripke in this years. Author mentions researches of Norman Malcolm, Charles Hartshorne, and Alvin Plantinga since they are extremely important for subsequent investigations.

The second part “The level of semantics” author states of previously own researches. The general idea is multilevel possible world semantics where each level contains the only one sort of essences. The essences of the level can exist in weak of strong sensesEvery level has to be arranged to others levels by principle of Coherent Demanding. . The essences of different levels exist in different senses. The one level is especial – its essences exist “really”. So, really exist state of affairs. God is not state of affairs and not the object like tree, hill, or human. God is especially object, the property of arranging the worlds, the law of construction the system of worlds at all.

The third part “The level of Methodology” author tries to connect own semantics idea of God to V.A. Smirnov’s idea of empirical and theoretical objects. As a result, author concludes that God is theoretical object in methodological sense.

In the fourth part “God as office and as theoretical object” author analyses the possibility of conjunction of methodological idea of V.A. Smirnov on the one side, and the semantics idea of P. Tichy on the other. Here is arise some problem which author doesn’t try to solve in these article.

In the conclusion author deals with results of research So, she also ascribe some ways of following investigation.

Added: Dec 13, 2016
Article
Скиперских А. В. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2016. № 3 (35). С. 226-236.

This article seems to look at the issue of protest and its cultural predisposition. From the point of view of the author, the protest is dependent on the specific cultural area, on its structure. Russian culture, in a certain way, initially hampering rebel, is the best field for updating and application of protest practices.

Added: Nov 20, 2016
Article
Инишев И. Н. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2011. Т. 16. № 4. С. 86-93.
Added: Oct 10, 2012
Article
Рогонян Г. С. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2016. Т. 34. № 2. С. 110-118.

The aim of this paper is to explore how from an early age a person acquires an intuitive ideas about what are the thought and language, and how they relate to each other. The sum of intuitions of this kind can be called naive semantics, which is often one of the main targets for philosophical criticism. The overall objective of the paper is to show that such criticism is largely underestimates the value of naive semantics for our intellectual development and cognition, and that it usually incorrectly describes the origins of naïve semantics. In particular, the use of mentalistic idioms that characterize naive semantics is not a secondary and parasitic functioning of language, but a necessary and preliminary step in mastering of abstract, including scientific, concepts.

Added: Jul 12, 2016
Article
Князева Е. Н. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2016. № 3 (35). С. 23-35.

Some notions of the evolutionary ontological holism in ontological, cognitive and methodological aspects are discussed in the article. It is shown that holism becomes a new fundamental scientific paradigm that determines research strategies, while we return to the integrity of the knowledge, of life and activity orientations existed since ancient times. The ideas of holism become guidelines for creative minds that are flagships of social progress and determine the future of civilization.

Added: Dec 15, 2015
Article
Большаков Н. В. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2017. № 38. С. 154-165.

The analysis of the methodological and analytical experience of conducting the mixed methods research of deaf and hard of hearing people is considered in this article. Ratification of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities makes sociological study of people with various forms of disability especially relevant. At the same time, people with disabilities in most studies are analised as a homogeneous group which does not require differentiation of methods of their study. The lack of attention to people with hearing impairments, as an objects of various studies, usually leads to the use of research design, which ignores the cultural and linguistic features of this community. R.Winiarczyk and E.Wilson note that understanding of complex phenomena such as "culture of the deaf" can not be achieved by using only one research method. They suggest combining in-depth interviews, focus groups, surveys, observations and analysis of natural Documents within one study in order to obtain an valid result. In the described study was used the consecutive mixed methods design, in which the first qualitative stage allowed the full understanfing of the "Deaf culture" notion and selection of indicators for specific cultural practices of the community of people with hearing impairments. This information was later used during condicting a mass poll of deaf and hard of hearing respondents. The use of such design is optimal when the researcher needs the revealing of certain concepts and instrumental elaboration of concepts related to poorly studied groups. In general, the analysis of the structure of interrelated practices, preferences and motives of cultural consumption, which form the patterns of cultural consumption of the deaf and hard of hearing people, made it possible to identify three key sustainable models: "cultural inclusion," "cultural isolation," and "passive cultural consumption". Interrelation of both stages of the study allows us to conclude that specific cultural practices play a special role for deaf and hard of hearing people. Moreover, cultural institutions perform primarily communicative and social functions.

Added: Sep 14, 2017
Article
Мишура А. С. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2015. № 4. С. 309-317.

In this paper, I review and discuss the philosophy of action in Wittgenstein’s later works. Firstly, I discuss Wittgenstein’s criticism of the variety of contemporary theories in the philosophy of action. Secondly, part I propose the development of Wittgenstein’s critical remarks in two general directions 1) naturalistic; 2) transcendental.

Added: Sep 25, 2015
Article
Кречетова М. Ю. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2011. № 2(14). С. 122-129.
Added: Oct 21, 2012
Article
Гуляев Р. В. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2017. № 37. С. 16-29.

The article is devoted to the problem of personal and political responsibility in works of Hannah Arendt, the German-American political theorist. Her main study on this subject, «Eichmann in Jerusalem», is presented as an argument against theory of national interest and its main contributor Carl Schmitt.

Added: Oct 23, 2014
Article
Мельникова Е. А. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2018. № 1(41). С. 142-149.
Added: Nov 14, 2017
Article
Шпаковская Л. Л. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2013. № 1. С. 236-249.
Added: Apr 11, 2013
Article
Небольсин Д. И. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2018. № 41. С. 15-23.

The aim of this article is to display the constitutive features of analytic philosophy of depiction (APD), a research field barely represented in Russian scientific literature. While sharing some core methodological implications and stylistic patterns with other subdivisions of analytic philosophy, APD tends to form rather enclosed philosophical community with its distinctive theoretical “canon” and highly specialized set of research questions. Philosophers of depiction explore the concept of picture rather than more conventional and broadly understood ‘image’. From this perspective pictures are defined as two-dimensional objects simultaneously possessing some material vehicle (plane, surface) and some visual representational content. Philosophical understanding of pictures usually presupposes reflecting on problems of how pictorial representation works and in which respect it differs from other representational systems, of how ontological duality of depiction may be explained and of how to discern the conditions and singularities of pictorial experience and basic pictorial understanding. Some of these questions were initially posed by philosophers of art, but APD has already obtained theoretical independence from aesthetics at the current stage of its development. The core APD accounts include illusion theory (E.H. Gombrich), structural theories (N. Goodman, J. Kulvicki), seeing-in and twofoldness theory (R. Wollheim), make-believe theory (K. Walton), recognitional theories (F. Schier, D.M. Lopes) and experienced resemblance theories (J. Hyman, R. Hopkins). It is shown that despite their radical discrepancies, they share core standards of argumentation along with tendency to provide “strong” but concise explanations of depiction-related problems as well as to introduce novel, unorthodox notions in order to make their conceptual apparatuses more specified, fine-grained and nuanced. The most original and somewhat idiosyncratic feature of APD is that it generally avoids preoccupations with historical, political or ideological implications of pictures and social conditions of their production, circulation and reception. Hence any further applications of APD’s theoretical accomplishments have a strong need to be supported by comparisons with other directions of research concerning the pictorial and the visual (such as interdisciplinary image studies, visual studies, iconology etc.).

Added: Aug 20, 2018
Article
Рогонян Г. С. Вестник Томского государственного университета. Философия. Социология. Политология. 2015. Т. 32. № 4. С. 333-344.

The article discusses the sentential approach to the analysis of propositional attitudes. As a rule, the main tool for interpretation of another's speech and behavior – attitude of holding-true a sentence - escapes our attention in conversation. The reason for this is largely due to the fact that the requirement for a holistic approach to our beliefs depends on the semantic indeterminacy of translation. Author of the article suggests that widened understanding of semantical anomalies can clarify why sentential structure of propositional attitudes usually escapes our attention.

Added: Jan 22, 2016